Friday, February 1, 2008

Ash Wednesday


Remember, man, that you are dust,and into dust you shall return.

The winter skies hang over Seattle, heavy and gray. The air is cold and damp. Rain may fall or, perhaps, drizzle may drizzle. And even when moisture doesn't fall to the ground, and down our necks, it still floats in the air, chilling us through our coats as we struggle through it. The wind blows hard against us, changing direction in gusts. The unlucky homeless huddle on the streets, their cardboard signs soggy, waiting hopelessly to be noticed.

Next week is Ash Wednesday. Not an American sort of holiday, is it? No happy families, gathered cozily about the dinner table. No decorations. No buying frenzies by crazed shoppers. No Santa Claus, no Easter Bunny, no displays of fireworks. Norman Rockwell never painted a family celebrating Ash Wednesday. It's a quiet day, a sober day, a day to be introspective. It is not a social observance. It's a time for us all to recall that our lives are not forever, that each of our lives had a finite beginning, and that each will have a finite end. An opportunity to consider what that unsettling fact must mean for us.

In this brief transit where the dreams cross
The dreamcrossed twilight between birth and dying.
--T. S. Eliot, Ash Wednesday

And yet, un-American as Ash Wednesday may appear, Americans of all ages will stream into their churches next week to observe this most unfestive of days. We'll stand in the damp and chill of mid-winter, remembering who we are. Remembering that, seen in the context of the centuries and millennia of human history that precede us, our lives are brief and soon over. There was an Anglo-Saxon monk, a fellow named Bede, who pondered this brevity long ago. He wrote on ancient parchment that our lives reminded him of a tiny sparrow that flies out of the cold winter night, through a window, and into a warm, cheerful, brightly-lit banquet hall -- and then swiftly flies right out again, back into the dark.

In that time in which it is indoors it is indeed not touched by the fury of the winter; but yet, this smallest space of calmness being passed almost in a flash, from winter going into winter again, it is lost to our eyes. Somewhat like this appears the life of man.

But we do not despair. Even now, even in these most depressing depths of winter, when all our world seems dead and lifeless, we note the first brave crocus buds forcing their way through the soil. The tiny crocuses, so easy to overlook, offer us hope; their appearance prefigures a new life to come. They serve as a sign to us of the approaching warmth, rebirth, growth and excitement of a new Spring.

We can certainly endure another six weeks or so of winter, can't we? In fact, if wise, we actually embrace the cold, the wet, the hardship. The sober darkness and silence we confront today, and in days to come, prepare us all the more fully for the infinite beauty of our promised Spring, in the same way as the agonizing absence of one's lover enhances the joy of the ultimate reunion.

We button our collars more securely, put our frozen hands into our pockets, and walk purposefully into the icy wind. We may crack a smile.

We may even whistle a little.

Sunday, January 27, 2008

“Not all those who wander are lost.”

    -- J.R.R. Tolkien


J.R.R. Tolkien's Lord of the Rings has fascinated the reading public since it was first published in the mid-20th century. From 10-year-olds reading wide-eyed under their bed covers, to college-aged hippies of the 1960's, to fantasy buffs of every age today, to merely casual viewers of Peter Jackson's award winning movie adaptation of the trilogy -- each of us, for reasons personal to his own nature, is enthralled by Tolkien's world of elves and men, dwarves and wizards, orcs and balrogs. And, of course, hobbits.

Tuesday, I will attend the third in a series of five lectures at the University of Washington by Robin Chapman Stacey, a UW professor of history. In her first two lectures, Professor Stacey has emphasized a fact well known to Tolkien devotees, but perhaps not to the general public: Tolkien was first and foremost an accomplished student of philology and languages. He also was something of an English eccentric, the sort of guy some of us would love to have known, a man of great curiosity who simply loved messing around with words, grammar, syntax -- inventing his own vocabularies and etymologies -- a curious form of recreation that dated back to his earliest childhood.

Tolkien's specialty, his real love, was the Scandinavian, Germanic and Celtic languages of northern Europe, hardly a surprise to any reader of LOTR who possesses even a casual acquaintance with those languages. While Tolkien "should" have been concentrating on his research as a Professor of Philology and Linguistics at Oxford, he spent much of his spare time making up pretend languages and figuring out the rules by which they were derived from earlier, more ancient (and equally fabricated) lost languages. Eventually, he felt he needed an historical and mythical context in which to flesh out and explain the world from which such languages evolved. Hence, his writing of LOTR, and of his earlier novel The Hobbit.

To anyone for whom wasting time pleasurably includes reading medieval history and sci-fi/fantasy, and thumbing through dictionaries seeking word meanings and derivations -- this writer cheerfully pleads guilty -- these lectures have been a joy to attend. The titles of the five weekly lectures in the series are:

l. "He has been inside language" (Tolkien's love of creating "nonsense languages")

2. "A mythology for England" (The Silmarillion as the back-story for LOTR)

3. "The war to end all wars" (impact of World War I on Tolkien's writing)

4. "A fundamentally religious work" (impact of Tolkien's Catholicism on his work)

5. "Allegory and farewell" (later adaptations and criticisms of his work)

Professor Stacey has pointed out that many of Tolkien's Oxford colleagues considered his fantasy writings an enormous waste of Tolkien's time. They were disappointed that a scholar with such impressive potential for linguistic research should have allowed his focus to be diverted by such childish pursuits.

J.R.R. Tolkien's writings have awakened interest, for untold numbers of readers, in the medieval world, in Nordic mythology, and in the way language develops and affects our lives. He has brought bittersweet joy to children and adults alike. (I once read of a sixth grade boy who cried for days -- heartbroken -- after he finished the last chapter of The Return of the King.) God had created our own world for our enjoyment, Tolkien believed. Therefore, true worship of God and gratitude for that creation required that he himself wield his pen to "sub-create" new worlds for us to inhabit and enjoy.

Like Philip Pullman, who apparently hated the works of both Tolkien and Tolkien's friend and Oxford colleague C.S. Lewis, Tolkien created an alternative world to our own crowded, increasingly homogeneous, modern Earth, a world of primitive beauty and terror that has the power to lift our hearts and minds to a higher plane, and then to return us to our own world as more sensitive and creative human beings.

Not a bad way to have your life remembered. Hardly a "waste of time," eh?

Saturday, January 26, 2008

An endorsement


The New York Times endorsed Hillary Clinton in its editorial pages yesterday. As the writer for the newspaper noted, Obama and Clinton have very similar views on issues of foreign and domestic policy. The race is not between conflicting policies, but between persons. The newspaper acknowledged Obama's strengths, and Clinton's weaknesses. The editorial encouraged Ms. Clinton to change the sometimes harsh tone of her campaign, to be more of a uniter and less of a divider.

But for the Times, the decisive issue is Hillary Clinton's "abiding, powerful intellect," and the depth of her knowledge and experience.

Well, gosh, if the New York Times can endorse candidates, why can't the Northwest Corner?

I agree with virtually everything stated in the fair and thoughtful Times editorial. I think either candidate would be an excellent president. But the critical factor not mentioned by the Times is "electability."

Obama inspires enthusiasm across a wide spectrum of Democrats and independents. Even some Republicans have tempting thoughts of jumping party lines in November. Hillary Clinton, on the other hand, faces the undying hostility of a significant fraction of the voters. This hostility is unfair. It's based on nothing rational. Her opponents can't explain their hatred of Ms. Clinton, at least in terms that make any sense to a rational listener. Fear of strong women probably plays some part in this hostility, but is not the only factor. Many of her detractors would have had no difficulty in voting for Margaret Thatcher.

In any event, nothing that Clinton can do will win these voters over between now and November. They are beyond logical argument, and Hillary can't turn herself into Laura Bush, if that's what it would take. If we subtract the Hillary-haters, what's left? Are there enough swing voters so eager to punish the Republicans for the misrule of the past eight years that they will vote for Hillary over any Republican candidate? A Republican candidate who even some Democrats find attractive, such as John McCain?

I don't know. And I'm not willing to gamble. Unless there develops a mob of anti-black, anti-Obama voters that is every bit as large and rabid as the gang of anti-Hillary haters -- in which case, this country is really in trouble -- I'll support Obama because (1) he will make a strong president, and (2) he can win.

I plan to vote for Barack Obama in the Washington caucuses on February 9.

--------------------
NOTE (1-27-08): In this morning's edition, the Seattle Times endorsed Obama for the Democratic nomination.

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

The Perils of Being an Actor


Members of Westboro Baptist Church of Topeka, Kansas, will picket the funeral of Australian actor Heath Ledger, who, among his many roles -- including the role of "The Joker" in a new Batman film to be released posthumously -- acted the part of a gay cowboy in Brokeback Mountain. In a press release, the Kansas church has attributed Ledger's death to "the wrath of God," wrath apparently incurred solely because of his cowboy role.

“Heath Ledger is now in Hell, and has begun serving his eternal sentence there,” the Westboro Baptist announcement says.
--Fox News

No slippery distinctions between character and actor muddy the fine clarity of Westboro Baptist's theology, it would appear. "All the world's a stage, and all the men and women merely players," etc. etc.

Readers may recall that Anthony Hopkins, even more shockingly, played Hannibal Lector, a murderer and eater of human flesh, in The Silence of the Lambs. Actor Hopkins thus, like Ledger, flagrantly disregarded yet another injunction found in the Book of Leviticus:

Do not eat meat with the blood still in it. Do not clip your hair at the temples, nor trim the edges of your beard. Do not ... tattoo yourselves.
--Leviticus 19:26-28 (emphasis added).

Be afraid, Mr. Hopkins. Be very afraid.

Saturday, January 12, 2008

Seahawks Dive


In keeping with the Northwest Corner's tradition of giving some notice, but only passing notice, to the local sports scene, I'll just observe that the Seahawks abruptly removed themselves from the NFL playoffs today. In a display of utter fecklessness before a national TV audience, the sort of stunned performance that endears Northwest teams to those of us here in Seattle, they swiftly surrendered an early 14-0 first quarter lead. Seemingly dazed by the onslaught of Wisconsin snow, Packer defenders, and Brett Favre passes, they come limping back to Seattle at the short end of a 42-20 final score. Wait 'til next year.

This result is worth noting only because of its consistency with other sports events this year

Seattle Mariners. An 88-74 season and second place AL West finish don't sound all that bad, but they hide a truly remarkable fin-de-saison collapse. From August 25 to September 11, the Mariners won 2 and lost 15 games, decisively dealing themselves out of contention for the division pennant, as well as the wild card and the playoffs. At least we still have Ichiro.

University of Washington. The once mighty Huskies ended up at the very bottom of the Pac-10 standings with a 2-7 conference record (4-9 overall). No bowl game for these Dawgs. Grumblings became audible as some alumni sought the scalp of one of the classiest coaches in college football, Tyrone Willingham. Meanwhile, the disgraced coach who contributed to this sad state of affairs was hired as head coach by UCLA. "Bow down to Washington ... heaven help the foes of Washington!" Yeah, right.

Seattle Supersonics. Yeah, they are still around, barely. At present, their win-loss record is 9-27, making them the 27th best team out of 30 in the NBA. Oh well, good enough for Oklahoma City, I guess.

All this, and months of rain as well. It's enough to keep Californians down there south of the Siskiyous where they belong. Me? I think I'll go see a good movie.

Thursday, January 10, 2008

His Final Summit



Statue of Sir Edmund Hillary, with Everest in background

Life in our century doesn't offer many heroes. Men's greatest achievements seem soon tarnished by rumors of steroids, bribes, gambling scandals, ghost-written books, domestic violence. Apparent heroes end up on inane talk shows, revealing themselves to be self-centered jerks.

But today, a true hero died.

Sir Edmund Hillary has passed away at the age of 88. On May 29, 1953, he and his Sherpa companion Tenzing Norgay were the first human beings ever to reach the summit of Mount Everest.

In 1953, Everest was a remote peak in an inaccessible kingdom. Fat cat businessmen couldn't pay $60,000 -- or any price at all -- to be hauled up the mountain by guides, or to drag themselves up by use of fixed ropes. Helicopters didn't fly to base camp with fresh supplies. Simply reaching what is now "Everest Base Camp" required a major expedition.

Major corporations did not sponsor climbs. Climbers did not wear company logos. Climbers did not keep in touch with their families by radio, and certainly not by email. The Kingdom of Nepal limited access to the area to one expedition per year. Sir Edmund, then a simple New Zealand beekeeper, made his climb as part of an official expedition by the British Royal Geographical Society. He climbed the final stretch to the summit, from 27,900 feet, together with Tenzing Norgay, giving his name to the "Hillary step," a 40-foot cliff that every summiteer must negotiate just before the summit.

Word of his triumph reached London during the coronation ceremonies for Queen Elizabeth II. His triumph was viewed as a triumph for the entire British Commonwealth and Empire.

The newspapers will be full of the story tomorrow, as will the newsmagazines. I won't try to tell their story here. Although the expedition was a team effort, Sir Edmund's success was also celebrated as a victory for the individual spirit, as inspiring in its way as the later American moon landing was as a national endeavor. Sir Edmund himself became a celebrity and a hero.

But, for me, he remains a hero because of the way he spent his remaining 54 years of life.

He never forgot that his climb had been possible only because of his Sherpa support. In an era when European supremacy was often taken for granted, he never revealed, at least as long as Tenzing Norgay remained alive, which climber first set foot on the summit -- as if who was "first" even mattered. He saw and he was moved by the deep spirituality and the harmony with nature of the Sherpa people. He also saw, and was moved, by the Sherpas' material poverty, and their lack of education and health care. Although he served for a time as New Zealand's ambassador to India (and Nepal), he devoted much of his remaining life to raising money for schools and hospitals in the Khumbu region, and to preserving the Khumbu's environment from degradation by climbers and trekkers.

Today, anyone who visits the Khumbu (the Everest region populated by the Sherpa people) will encounter the schools and the medical facilities made possible by Sir Edmund's efforts. Visitors will meet the Sherpa people -- still sturdy, hard-working and poor -- but now healthier and with more hope for the future than they could have anticipated but for his efforts.

"I cannot do everything, but I can do something." Sir Edmund's life exemplifies the spirit behind that saying. At 88, he has now climbed his final summit. He has achieved his ultimate success. He lived, and he has died, a hero.
----------------------------------
AUTHOR'S NOTE (1-12-08): The following anecdote is from this week's Time Magazine. Edmund Hillary's life is a beacon of sanity and selflessness in contrast to everything that is wrong about today's "celebrities."

"I never deny the fact that I think I did pretty well on Everest," he [Sir Edmund] told a reporter in 1992. "But I was not the heroic figure the media and the public made me out to be."

Once, while resting on a rock during a short trek in Nepal with friend and film director Michael Dillon, an American walker stopped and showed Hillary how to hold an ice-axe. "Hillary listened and thanked him, but said nothing else," remembers Dillon. "The American went away without any idea whom he had spoken to." The first man to stand on top of the world didn't see himself as a hero. Others always will.

Friday, January 4, 2008

A Tiny Ripple of Hope


It is from numberless diverse acts of courage and belief that human history is thus shaped. Each time a man stands up for an ideal, or acts to improve the lot of others, or strikes out against injustice, he sends forth a tiny ripple of hope, and crossing each other from a million different centers of energy and daring, those ripples build a current which can sweep down the mightiest walls of oppression and resistance.
--Robert F. Kennedy (1966)

This week, I've heard a haunting melody, a stirring rhythm, arising from the small towns and cornfields of Iowa; I've felt a trembling in the earth, a promise of change that sends a shiver down my spine. I feel the first tentative hope for the dawning of one more renewal in American political life, hope that arrives just when I feared we no longer were capable, or deserving, of such renewal.

Barack Obama. Age 46. Half Kenyan, half Kansan. A black man who speaks Indonesian, graduated from Hawaii's most exclusive prep school, and served as president of the Harvard Law Review. An Illinois liberal who speaks a new political language, a language that appeals to a broader audience. An African-American civil rights advocate who captures the hearts of white Iowa voters. A U.S. Senator. A successful middle-aged politician who can't help looking like a geeky kid speaking at graduation.

How unlikely a voice seems Mr. Obama's, how unlikely that his should be the voice crying in the wilderness, crying that we should make straight our paths. And yet. And yet, I dare to hope.

He would be but the latest avatar of an historical American type -- the political evangelist, calling the nation to renewal and to new achievement. We recall Teddy Roosevelt, leading the country forth from the corruption and torpor of the late 19th century. FDR, assuring us that we had nothing to fear but fear itself. Bobby Kennedy, quoting George Bernard Shaw: "There are those who look at things the way they are, and ask why... I dream of things that never were and ask why not."

But what is Barack Obama's program, skeptics ask? It's important to know, of course, and his Democratic rivals demand to know. If Obama has any hope of succeeding in his campaign, we will know more in coming weeks. But the details of his platform, as opposed to its broad outlines, matter little -- few campaign promises survive the crash and shock of unanticipated crises. They matter little, except insofar as they show the measure of the man.

Teddy Roosevelt's program was an unexceptional populism. FDR's New Deal often bordered on a form of fascism, and much of it was held unconstituional. Robert Kennedy stole Gene McCarthy's program, in many respects, and repackaged it in a form more digestible to more people.

The details of their programs were vague before they were elected (or assassinated), and in some respects were unworkable if and when enacted. The real legislative successes of these leaders were ones hammered out as the need arose, in consultation with leaders in Congress. What these men did give us, however, by force of their personality and their ability to "connect" with the electorate, was hope. Hope for a better America than was offered by the corporate greed of Gilded Age capitalism. Hope in the midst of the Depression for a return to prosperity. Hope for a return to peace in Vietnam, and for an America the young could once more love and respect.

Forty years after RFK electrified the nation, Barack Obama appears on the scene. Obama just may be offering our generation a new hope, hope for an escape from the gravest deadend and paralysis in American politics since the Civil War -- our seemingly irreversible polarization between two mutually hostile and uncomprehending factions.

It's too early to tell whether Obama is capable of carrying our dreams upon his shoulders, and offering back the hope we need. It's also too early to judge whether he has the qualities necessary to govern the nation as President, as opposed to simply inspiring it as orator. But, experience and detailed programs are not always presidential prerequisites. Presidents grow in office. Harry Truman was a political unknown (outside Missouri) when he became President.

Finally, I'm well aware that it is failing and floundering societies that hunger most urgently for inspiring, rather than simply competent, leaders. Such a hunger can be irrational and dangerous. Hitler and Mussolini each assumed such an inspirational role, seizing power when citizens in their own countries became fearful and desperate. Focus on the character of the leader rather than the workability of his proposals is risky.

But historically, we have been more fortunate than have countries like Germany and Italy. Our hunger for change has always been tempered by common sense. Our own political "saviors" -- our Roosevelts (both of them), our Kennedys, our Lincolns -- have been inspiring men, rational men -- not perfect men, but men who each led us out of the wilderness of his time and made the country governable once more by the capable but less charismatic Presidents who followed.

God, they say, has a special place in his heart for children, idiots, and the United States of America. Maybe so.

We live in interesting times. Let's keep our eyes and ears open and our hopes high in the weeks ahead.

Sunday, December 30, 2007

Glückliches Neues Jahr!

Alan and Scout at dinner.

So many of our traditional Christmas observances come from Germany, or northern Europe in general -- the Christmas tree, mistletoe, St. Nicholas (Santa Claus) (not the original saint, but the Christmas trappings), wassail bowl ("glühwein"), and many of the Christmas carols.

Several of our family members were able to experience a German Christmas this year -- German, but tempered with familiar American customs. I arrived home from Stuttgart last night, where we'd been the guests of Suzanne and Alan for ten days.
Alan serves with the USMC, often away on worldwide missions, but based in Germany.

Their hospitality was overwhelming!

My own favorite memories:

  • Our picturesque hotel for three nights in the little Black Forest village of Obereichenbach.
  • "Shopping" for cuckoo clocks in Triberg, and hiking up to the frozen waterfall.
  • Walking with Scout and family on hikes through the frozen fields and woods near Suzanne and Alan's house.
  • Go-Kart racing! After half an hour, my eyes were glazed and my fingers had to be pried loose from the steering wheel.
  • Visiting the military hospital at the U.S. base at Landstuhl.
  • Our whirlwind overnight visit to Strasbourg in near-by France.
  • One wonderful meal after another, from a three-star restaurant in the heart of the Black Forest, to a meter-long bratwurst bought from a little booth at the Christmas fair in Stuttgart. Having Scout be permitted to join us at restuarant meals.
  • Barton's retirement dinner, where the chief waiter presented him with the world's most appropriate retirement present. The waiter's witty speech almost outshone the gift itself.
  • Our last-day visit to the Mercedes-Benz museum, in the auto maker's home town. The museum displayed a fascinating history of the development of automotive science and design, told in the context of the social and political history of the 20th century, especially in Germany.

A great visit. Thanks so much to Alan and Suzanne. Thanks also to all the other members of the family, whose presence made this a most memorable Christmas.

----------------------------
NOTE FROM AUTHOR: November and December have been odd months, with family trips and family holidays diverting my attention. The few posts published in those months have tended to be of interest only to family members themselves. With the beginning of 2008, the Northwest Corner will return to its regular programming -- topics that I hope will be of interest to all readers.

Monday, December 17, 2007

Season's Greetings!


Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays!


The Northwest Corner once more shuts down while its writer, yours truly, joins family in Stuttgart, Germany, to celebrate Christmas. My best holiday wishes to all my family, friends, regular readers, potential readers, former readers. To all of America, to all of humanity. To (as our very wise Buddhist friends would say) all sentient beings.


I'll be back home on December 29, and will rejoin you here in the blogosphere for a very interesting and rewarding 2008. Have a great holiday season!

Friday, December 14, 2007

Lyra's World at the Movies


No movie can fully capture the depth and complexity and magic of a good book. The Lord of the Rings trilogy perhaps came closest, but, good as the film versions were, they emphasized endless battle scenes at the expense of some of the more subtle messages of Tolkien's books. To me, a fundamental theme of the written LOTR trilogy was the theme of loss, the sense that when one fights a war, even the winner loses much that he had fought to save. Return of the King tried to convey this sense of loss in its final, much-ridiculed half hour, at the Grey Havens, but by that time it was perhaps too late.

Back in May, I wrote with anticipation of the long-awaited filming of the first book of Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials trilogy, The Golden Compass (published originally in Britain as Northern Lights). I concluded my post with the words: "Assuming the film bears any resemblance at all to the book, I say "two thumbs up" even before I see it! Don't miss it!"

The movie was released a week ago. The reviews have been mixed, and the first week's gross receipts, perhaps as a result, disappointing. Many have felt that the movie was less subtle, less complex, less intellectually satisfying, than the book. Well, duh! That's always the case. The movie presents in two hours a book that takes much longer to read, and that has room for far more complexity and development. Philosophical and theological ideas that develop slowly in the reader's awareness, absorbed from the plot itself, in a two hour movie must be presented either in narrative voice overs (parallel universes exist, a pompous voice exclaims at the outset, where humans have souls that look like animals!), or in unlikely lectures by characters, inserted in the midst of the plot. (If you hate such plot-slowing lectures, never read The DaVinci Code, where the author was unable to tell his story without such artifices even in a lengthy written novel.)

In the time available, I feel that the movie actually did a more than adequate job of presenting all the major events, characters, and plot developments of the book. This is a movie, like The Fellowship of the Ring, that will make far more sense and be more appealing to persons already familiar with the books. The movie moves quickly. The viewer has little time to mull over plot and character development before the next crisis, the next character, the next twist of plot, arrives on the scene. You can't turn back five pages to recall who had which daemon. But the film does a more than adequate job of laying the foundation -- and creating an appetite -- for the next of the series, The Subtle Knife.

Visually, the movie could hardly be better. In LOTR, we marveled at the integration of the computerized Gollum into the filming of the live characters. In The Golden Compass, an enormous number of animal daemons, witches, armored bears, and mechanical insects fight, talk, and maneuver along side the live action cast. It's all done so seamlessly that we hardly appreciate the technical skills involved.

And the daemons! As we gradually learn in the book, and as the voice-over informs us bluntly at the beginning of the movie, every human in Lyra's world has his or her appropriate daemon, an animal companion representing an embodiment of the human's soul. In the many mob scenes, all the humans have to be shown with their daemons -- whether these are large impressive animals for complex characters -- snow leopards, golden monkeys, wolves -- or small simple daemons for simple folks -- birds, small dogs. The filming is handled beautifully, and we quickly grow accustomed to Lord Asriel stalking into the room, his leopard at his side, or, more movingly, Lyra's loving daemon, still capable of changing into a bird or a cat when appropriate, but usually presented as an ermine with an expressive face. (The Texas pilot's daemon, a female rabbit with a sarcastic Texan drawl, is hysterically funny.)

Death in such a world is dramatic. In the book, when a human was killed his daemon quickly faded away. In the movie, his daemon explodes in a flash of light. Battle scenes are thus spectacular!

Finally, a serious concern even before the movie was made was how the director, Chris Weitz, would handle the religious question. In the book, Lyra's world was ruled by a version of the Catholic Church that had, in her world, adopted some aspects of Calvinism during the Reformation and had moved its headquarters to Geneva. The Church, in the book, is a malevolent force. Its leaders' objective is to maintain control over the people, and to protect them from "sin," which in the author's vision is the same as protecting them from true adulthood. In the first book's most devastating scene, only somewhat less affecting in the movie, the Church conducts experiments in an Arctic laboratory, experiments it hopes will find a way to eliminate sin by surgically cutting the bond between children and their daemons before the kids reach puberty. The vision of the little boy -- now effectively soulless -- crying all alone in the frozen North for his lost daemon is unforgettable.

New Line Cinema could not see any advantage to releasing a movie for young people that attacks -- even in an alien world -- an institution that resembles in any way Christianity in our world.

We knew that Pullman's professed atheism would have to be tamed to some degree in the movie. How much, no one was sure. This month's issue of the Atlantic Monthly contains a lengthy (and very interesting) article by Hanna Rosin arguing that the movie gutted the book, leaving behind a couple of hours of simple entertainment for the mass audience. "The studio opted to kidnap the book's body and leave behind its soul."

I disagree. First of all, the trilogy's "soul" was not a logical attack on religion. It was a fantasy with many themes. It described a malevolent, or at least sadly mistaken, Church. But it also described the Chuch's God as a pathetic, senile old man floating around in space, who in his elder days was dominated by his supposed subordinates. It presented angels -- good, bad, and a couple who were gay. It presented flying witches. It presented talking, armored bears of incredible strength and endurance. It presented pathways between universes.

No one, no child, would take any of this as anything but a ripping good yarn. A fairy tale, a story of "what if?" Insofar as it contained a message, it was a call for every person to grow up, take responsibility, seek out the unknown, be brave, sacrifice the self for the common welfare, and love others. Hardly subversive. Those who see it as an attack on religion should ask themselves why they see a greater relationship between the "Church" in Lyra's world and any religion in our own world than they do between any other of the story's fictional devices and anything we're familiar with. Both those who applaud and those who fear the movie -- as an attack on religion -- should ask themselves that question.

In any event, to answer the Atlantic's critique, I don't see that the movie seriously watered down the philosophical questions of the books, except insofar as necessary to make a short movie and to avoid unnecessary offense to Christians . The movie always refers to the Church as "the Magisterium," and in the only reference to the fictional God of that world calls him "the Authority." Anyone old enough to be interested in the movie, beyond the level of cheering for awesome fights between armored bears, will recognize the religious references. Anyone that old, I would hope, also recognizes a fantasy when he or she sees one.

So my pre-release verdict from last spring holds. "Two thumbs up. Go see it!"

(But you really should read the books first!)

-------------
(12-16-07) -- The movie has drawn an extraordinary amount of comment on the internet, much of it from Christian writers. The majority of Christian commentators appear to feel that the movie, and even more the books, present a threat to children's faith. Others, however, view the movie as a well-produced fantasy, one that is not only entertaining but that presents parents with an opening for serious discussions of religious faith and theology with their children.

The Pullman trilogy is an "ode to the joy of living in a physical world, a hymn to flesh, to exuberance, to the here and now, to free thought, imagination and feeling, to nobility of spirit," according to a review by Washington Post book critic Michael Dirda.

"I happen to think that these positive traits are entirely compatible with organized religion and so I choose to focus on the positive rather than on any anti-religious themes in these books," said Paul Lauritzen, director of the Program in Applied Ethics at Jesuit-run John Carroll University in Cleveland, commenting on Dirda's review. Lauritzen is a contributor to dotCommonweal, a blog run by the Catholic magazine Commonweal.
--© 2007 Catholic News Service/USCCB

The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ Office for Film and Broadcasting gave the film, which is rated PG-13, a warm review. The film is not blatantly anti-Catholic but a “generalized rejection of authoritarianism,” it said.

While noting the story’s “spirit of rebellion and stark individualism,” the office said Lyra and her allies’ stand for free will in opposition to the coercive force of the Magisterium is “entirely in harmony with Catholic teaching.”
--MSNBC (11-30-07)



Wednesday, December 5, 2007

Laos & Cambodia, 2007

Here are some random photos,

giving a sampling of the sights we saw


Sunset over the Mekong River. Luang Prabang, Laos.










Young Buddhist monk















Hiking a dusty road in Laos
(accompanied by chickens)
















Angkor Wat, Cambodia














Kayaking in the Nam Song River

Near Vang Vieng, Laos












Buddhist monks.
















Highland Lao village boys,
playing soccer

Northern Laos











Denny demonstrating favorite pasttime

Drinking beer.

Vang Vieng, Laos






Killing fields of the Khmer Rouge
1975-79

Skulls displayed in memorial stupa

Phnom Penh, Cambodia

Monday, December 3, 2007

And the Sun comes up like Thunder


Oh, East is East, and West is West, and never the twain shall meet. --Kipling

Kipling may have been a bit of a racist, but he hit the bull's eye when it comes to time zones. After two weeks of living on Southeast Asia time, I now find myself suddenly standing on my head: Noon is midnight, and midnight is noon. My stomach is thinking about lunch when the night is darkest.

Tomorrow I go to work. I suspect I'll be dreaming of a soft bed about the time lunch is served.

Today's confused traveler navigates between East and West by existing -- you can't call it living -- for about 24 hours in a comatose gray zone, a twilight zone of the soul, a state we can call Airline World. In Airline World -- which encompasses airports as well as the airplanes themselves -- it's never a.m. or p.m., light or dark -- it's always "fluorescent light time." It's neither sleep time nor meal time. No one ever really sleeps, and meals are always available and are always being served.

In Airline World, one dwells in neither East nor West, but in a global culture of blandness and boredom. An airport in Bangkok is different from an airport in San Francisco only in its superficial (and institutional) decorative touches. A flight on Vietnam Airlines differs from a flight on Alaska Airlines only because you're forced to hear one or more additional translations of the same old AirlineSpeak flight instructions whose English versions you've long ago memorized. "Welcome to Siem Reap. Please check about your seat and in the overhead compartments for any personal belongings you may have overlooked. We will be deplaning through the left forward exit. Thank you again for flying with us today. We hope to see you again soon. Have a nice day in Siem Reap or wherever your travel plans may take you."

But your existence for 24 hours or so in Airline World is a necessary evil if you're ever to make the transition between East and West, the twain of which -- as Kipling has reminded us -- never meet. While your brain is stepped down into a low energy state, sensing only gray vision and white noise, it is being reprogramed to confront the world outside your airport of arrival. Not just to confront the disorienting change of time zones, vital to you as that will be, but to adapt your life to the changes in customs and world views as well. I suspect that Airline World allows some earlier-installed software to run inside you, resulting in the conversion:

IF new time zone is GMT minus 5 -8, THEN DELETE "smiling at strangers."
DELETE "living in the present."
DELETE "sensing and expressing esthetic pleasure in small beauties of life."
DELETE "attempting to appreciate cultural differences."
RESTORE "USA Daily Life Craziness software package"

So here I am, 12 hours after arrival in Seattle, and 12 hours until my first post-vacation work day begins. My computer brain has completed all the above deletions, leaving me in a state of passive grayness that obviously prevents me from writing a coherent blog posting. But still unrestored and uninstalled is the Daily Life Craziness package, the set of conditioned reflexes that creates my illusion of meaningfulness and self-importance, that enables me to live life from day to day with what is laughingly called an integrated personality.

Finally, ignore all the above jet-lag-induced ravings. Denny and I had a great trip. Southeast Asia is a beautiful part of the world, populated by beautiful and graceful people. I have much still to ponder about my brief two weeks of travel in the area. Some of my ultimate observations will probably trickle forth into these pages from time to time. Meanwhile:

"Had a wonderful time. Wish you'd been there. Nice to be back."

Photo: Tonle Sap lake, near Siem Reap, Cambodia. Taken 12/2/07.

Monday, November 12, 2007

Closed for Renovation



Be Back


In


December










The World Famous Northwest Corner will be closed for a little sprucing up over the next couple or three weeks. A few repairs, a little remodeling, a touch of paint here and there. A new, more contemporary look. Strengthening of structural elements. Better plumbing and more electric. A more rational layout

No, no, no. I'm not talking about the Corner being spruced up! I'm talking about me! The Corner will merely be closed while I'm renovating myself. I'll be off in the wilds of Southeast Asia (see earlier posts), rebuilding mind, soul and body. I'll come back as a new, sleeker, wittier, more sarcastic (but I mean that in the best possible way) model; a less tired, jaded, cliché-ridden and jejune Rainier96.

And, of course, with a newly acquired taste for rice. You're gonna love the changes.

While I'm gone:

1. Have a wonderful Thanksgiving.

2. Look forward eagerly to the opening of the movie version of Philip Pullman's The Golden Compass, due for release the first week of December. (See earlier post.)

3. Check your sports pages to see whether it is Washington or Stanford that finally ends up at the very bottom of the PAC-10 standings.

4. Hope that the Administration doesn't reach for one last-ditch grasp at success and historical relevancy by invading Iran.

5. Keep track of how many more Republicans decide not to run for re-election in 2008, so they can spend more time with their families. Or their dogs. Or to take up origami as they've always dreamed of doing.

6. Await with anticipation Zachary's announcement of which colleges he's applying to this fall.

7. And ... wait eagerly for the re-opening for business of The Northwest Corner by its renovated proprietor.

Thursday, November 8, 2007

Take the "A" Train ... Please


San Francisco has BART, a sleekly beautiful interurban system. Washington, D.C., has Metro. Chicago has the antique but serviceable "El" with all its municipal and interurban connections. New York has its gritty but efficient subway system. Atlanta has MARTA. Los Angeles has its Red and Purple lines.

These are all heavy rail systems, running off of electrified third rails. Seattle voted down an excellent, comprehensive area-wide system proposed in 1969. Seattle today has no heavy rail.

Portland has MAX, carrying passengers through downtown and to outlying areas. Colorful Los Angeles has its Gold, Blue and Green lines. Vancouver has its successful SkyTrain.

These are light rail systems, more like streetcars but running on dedicated off-road routes, for the most part, and powered by overhead lines. Seattle is building a light rail line from downtown to the airport, due to open in 2009, and is planning an extension northwards to the University, which may open in 2016. That's all we have in the way of light rail.

I'm depressed.

The light rail authorized to date will be nice for users of the airport, and the extension will be convenient for students. But it does not come close to a comprehensive rail transit system. And Tuesday, voters rejected a ballot measure that would have provided funding for an additional 50 miles of light rail, extending the system into Pierce County to the south and Snohomish County to the north. The measure lost by a decisive margin.

This city has enormous difficulty in carrying through on any project. Part of our problem seems to be the local press. Whenever a public project is suggested, the newspapers are full of excited stories and beautiful architectural drawings. Everyone professes excitement. The project goes forward. Then comes the election to provide financing. All of a sudden, new forces within the newspapers' management seem to surge to the surface. Stories of cost overruns and faulty estimates abound. Headlines warn voters of the increases to come in their tax bills if the measure is approved. Questions are raised -- does this project, paid for us all, only serve certain elite groups (or only poor folks, depending on the project), although paid for by everyone?

An editorial written by a senior editor in one of the two dailies, shortly before the election, was filled with dark forebodings of the money to be wasted, the boondoggle being thrust upon us. He ended with his coup de grâce-- ask yourselves, he wrote, how much good am I -- yes, me, myself, as an individual -- going to get out of this transit system? Ah yes, the attitude that made this country great: "What's in it for me?"

What's in it for me, of course, besides the fact that I think rail transit is inherently cool, is an electrically powered system of mass transit, separated for most of its route from motor vehicle traffic, and able to move people about the city, and to and from work, with a minimum amount of CO2 emissions, a minimum amount of energy consumption, and a maximum amount of speed.

Which brings us to the Sierra Club. I'm a long-time member and fervent supporter of the Sierra Club. The Club has done wonderful work in setting aside wilderness areas and parks, work for which future generations will owe them immense gratitude. But the local chapter of the Sierra Club may well have tipped the balance in ensuring defeat of the rapid transit measure. The problem, for the Club's decision makers, was that the proposition also authorized a large amount of road and bridge construction. They opposed making it easier to drive cars.

I'm not an automobile enthusiast. I love visiting New York and European cities, places where you can spend days traveling around by transit, without needing a car and where a car is merely an encumbrance. But Seattle is not that kind of city yet. It wouldn't have been, even with 50 more miles of rail transit, and even with an excellent Metro bus system. A large percentage of the population will need to depend on motor vehicle transportation for the foreseeable future. As the density of transit routes and the frequency of service increase, that percentage will decrease. But for now, traffic is a nightmare. Road improvements are necessary. The objective is to improve roads and bridges with as little impact on the surrounding community as possible.

To the Sierra Club, half measures were unacceptable. They were unwilling to accept increased road construction in order to get the improved rail transit that will make even greater road construction in the future less necessary. I think that was a mistake.

So I'm depressed. I'm depressed that Seattle has talked about rail transit for so many decades, and has so little to show for it. I'm depressed at the part that the media have played in the debacle of this election. I'm depressed at the role played by the Sierra Club, an organization with whom I feel close ties.

And I'm generally depressed at our inability as a community to make decisions and work together to accomplish what we set out to do.

Monday, November 5, 2007

A Saturday Idyll




Sunset and evening star,
And one clear call for me!
And may there be no moaning of the bar,
When I put out to sea.


--Tennyson

A bright sun. A warm day. A dark blue sky. A peaceful Bay. White sails, rocky cliffs, graceful bridges, playful seals. A happy, laughing crew. And always, in the background, the skyline of San Francisco.

I flew down Friday night, and Chris -- an old hiking buddy and our skipper for the day -- met me at the airport and drove me to his home on Russian Hill. The next morning, three of Chris's friends dropped by and joined us. We drove to the marina in Berkeley, where family members from Sonoma were waiting. The eight of us -- three of us competent sailors, of whom I was not one -- set sail -- well, started the engine, actually -- on an excellent and attractive 36-foot sailboat and successfully navigated out of the marina and into San Francisco Bay for a day of sailing.

Well, for the most part, cruising.

Actually, you see, for much of the day, we were as becalmed at sea as an Ancient Mariner with an Albatross hung round his neck. But, hey, it was all good.

We sailed -- powered -- past Alcatraz with all its dark associations, around to the north side of Angel Island, where we disembarked and tested our land legs. The island -- where Chinese immigrants passed through American immigration back in the 19th century, on their way to backbreaking work on railroad crews -- is now a state park. We stopped for a snack at the small concession stand, and then hiked some distance up the trail, walking past one spectacular view after another, views of the Bay and its environs. Kathy was far in front and seemed bound for the summit, persuaded that it would take no time at all to successfully assault the 488-foot "peak." But cooler heads -- prompted by disgruntled cell phone calls from the more nautical members of our crew, waiting impatiently back at the pier -- prevailed. We skipped our way back down the trail to our awaiting boat.

To the west loomed the Golden Gate. We argonauts sailed -- powered -- our way to the ocean, passing under the ever-graceful bridge itself. We kept a nervous eye skyward, watching nervously for descending suicidal bodies. But the day obviously was too nice -- too nice even for a Californian who had lost his Prozac -- for anyone to feel sufficiently depressed for such an act of finality.

We looked astern (as we say in sailing biz), and enjoyed specacular views of the City, its hills and skyscrapers, framed between the bright orange twin towers of the bridge. The ocean was truly "pacific," its surface as calm as that of the Bay itself. But then, just as nervous images flashed through our minds, images of rogue currents bearing us off Japanwards, we prudently executed a broad U-turn and headed back into the safety of the Bay

We skirted the marina and Fisherman's Wharf areas of the City, watching tourists and dogs at play in city parks, and then cut the power a final time, hoisted the mainsail and unfurled the jib (I show off my nautical jargon before I once more forget it), caught a light north wind in our sails, and skimmed peacefully eastwards, back towards Berkeley.

A get-together for drinks at Chez Chris on Russian Hill, and a seafood (of course!) dinner near Fisherman's Wharf brought us to a tired and happy conclusion of a memorable Saturday in the Bay Area.