When John Smith, Sr., was 18, he spent a year in China on a church mission. While there, he met a local girl; one thing led to another, and his son was born in Hong Kong. The couple never married, but John returned to the United States with his baby, John Jr. Immigration officials assumed that the baby was a citizen and did not ask for documentation.
John Jr. grew up in the U.S. and never returned to China or Hong Kong. When he was 29, John Jr. was convicted of "trademark counterfeiting" and served a short term in prison. On his release, he was ordered deported to China as an alien. Just seven days later, he was put on a plane to Hong Kong.
Children of American parents born overseas usually become American citizens by birth. However, for a citizen father to pass on American citizenship to his child born overseas, he must have lived in the U.S. for at least five years after the age of 14. Since John Jr.'s father was only 18 when his son was born, it was impossible for him to meet that requirement, and John Jr. did not qualify for citizenship.
Following his deportation, John Jr. hired a lawyer and filed a motion to re-open the matter, based on constitutional objections to the statute under which he had been deported. But another surprise awaited him: a statute provides that once the claimant leaves the U.S., by deportation or otherwise, he is barred from re-opening the question of his citizenship and deportation.
John Jr., thankfully, is not a real person. But he could have been, and his story may in fact be based on a real set of facts.
I served on a three-attorney panel last night at the University of Washington law school, judging the semi-finals of an appellate advocacy competition. As usual, the student "lawyers" were excellent. Since the participants were students who had survived earlier rounds and had reached the semi-finals, I was seeing some of the best of the best. Their legal arguments involved minute dissection of a web of statutory and regulatory law, as well as issues of constitutional law.
But I tell John Jr.'s story because it points out how absurd America's immigration laws can be in practice, and the gross injustices that can result in individual cases. As one of my fellow judges asked the "U.S. Attorney," what's to stop California police from sweeping up large numbers of persons with Hispanic names or appearances on routine drug charges, for an immigration judge to determine that those unable to produce appropriate documentation are illegal aliens, and for them to be deported virtually overnight to Mexico? American citizens caught up in this drug sweep, unable for some reason to produce proof of citizenship before the immigration hearing would -- once deported -- be unable to re-open the queston of their citizenship once they ended up in Mexico.
Our fictitious John Jr. came to the U.S. as a baby in his father's arms. He grew up an American, with no subsequent contact with China. Both he and his father believed he was an American. Twenty-nine is a late age for such a person to learn for the first time that he's actually Chinese. Seven days after that determination is an early time to find oneself on a one-way flight to China. But, as the student attorney for the government pointed out, under present law, not even excusable ignorance of your non-citizenship is a bar to deportation.
This moot court appeal points out one of the many ways in which American immigration law -- rigidly applied as it is, with no real sense of equity in individual cases -- is unfair both to American citizens somehow caught up in it, and to those who would be American citizens but for a technicality of which they were understandably unaware.
Wednesday, February 22, 2012
Deportation
Posted by
Rainier96
at
9:18 AM
0
comments
Tuesday, February 21, 2012
A rustle in the dark
... as you may well imagine, the Professor's views on certain points are less clear cut than they used to be. His nerves, too, have suffered: he cannot even now see a surplice hanging on a door quite unmoved, and the spectacle of a scarecrow in a field late on a winter afternoon has cost him more than one sleepless night.
--M. R. James, "Oh, Whistle, and I'll Come to You, My Lad"
Thus ends one of M. R. James's most famous horror stories, a story about something that comes when one whistles, something that embodies itself in crumpled bed linen. Linen that moves about the room at night.
I re-read James's masterpiece after reading an article about the author's life and work in last week's New Yorker. James was the quiet, studious provost at King's College, Cambridge. He spent his life locating and poring over old manuscripts. But he's best known for writing several volumes of chilling short stories.
James was an interesting character, and his stories may or may not be self-revelatory psychologically. But the stories are the sort that make the hair rise on the back of your neck, despite a total absence of blood, gore, and decapitations. Merely a sheet on a bed that moves about -- once the candle is snuffed out.
The New Yorker article, and my subsequent glancing back through a volume of James's stories, instantly took me back to a summer day when I was 14. It was a hot day, and I had walked over to the house of a vacationing aunt and uncle, where I performed my daily job of moving the sprinklers from place to place about the yard. I had brought a recently-purchased book with me -- Tales of Terror, edited by Boris Karloff. I set up the sprinklers in their initial positions, got them running, and went inside the cool house to relax and amuse myself for a half hour until I'd have to move them again.
The story I began reading was -- as I now discover -- a classic: "The Willows," by Algernon Blackwood. A camping story, about a couple of men who are canoeing down the Danube near the Austrian/Hungarian frontier. They pull up to a small sandy island to spend the night, an island forested with willow trees. During a night somewhat reminiscent of the Blair Witch Project, they sense that the willows are malevolent or are at least the expressions of something that's malevolent. At the climax of the story, the body of a peasant floats past their campsite with bizarre funnel shaped gouges in his face, the mark of whatever forces surround them in the willows.
Blackwood's story ends. But before I finished reading, I became conscious that I was sitting and reading all alone in a cool, dark, quiet house -- a small, simple rambler with which I was totally familiar -- and that my heart was pounding. The house was dead silent, except for the slow "tick tock" of a pendulum clock on the mantle. Not only the house was silent, but the entire world, indoors and outdoors, seemed hushed.
I quickly exited the cool house and sat on the back porch in the hot sun. I continued reading. I still had a couple of hours of sprinkling to oversee. But I read outdoors, free of whatever menace my aunt's normally friendly home, now at my back, seemed to offer.
A truly well written ghost story, or "tale of terror," doesn't jump at you or spatter you with gore. It merely suggests that all is not as you think it is, that worlds exist far beyond our powers of perception, and that those worlds may well be hostile and menacing. A world, as "The Willows" suggests, which is
a new order of experience, and in the true sense of the word unearthly, [a world where] great things go on unceasingly...vast purposes...that deal directly with the soul, and not indirectly with mere expressions of the soul, ... an alien world, a world tenanted by willows only and the souls of willows.
For some reason, I felt safe sitting outside, where the sun beat down on me, the breeze blew in the trees, and the sprinklers spurted rhythmically. I hadn't yet read anything by M. R. James. His stories would have warned me that the greatest horrors can present themselves in the most pleasant, mundane and unassuming of locations.
The ability to be scared out of your wits by a good yarn is part of the charm of being 14. It's surprising (and a bit alarming) how a good enough story can make your hair stand on end, even as an adult.
I can't find my old childhood copy of Tales of Terror. I've just now ordered a used copy through Amazon. Parts of us never grow up.
Posted by
Rainier96
at
2:16 PM
0
comments
Saturday, February 18, 2012
Why I'm not voting "libertarian"
As you approach the Grand Canyon, driving north from Phoenix and Flagstaff, you pass through the town of Tusayan, just five miles south of the national park boundary. Tusayan's 558 residents live in 313 households, clustered in an area of a quarter square mile. Its voters first voted to incorporate as a town in 2010.
The vote to incorporate followed strong lobbying from developers, businessmen who hoped to construct their proposed development with minimal governmental interference. The newly elected town council -- whose members now face a recall election next month -- obediently approved the requested development.
What kind of development did the council of this small town approve? How about 3 million square feet of hotels, spas and retail outlets -- in a town with a population of 558? According to a story in today's New York Times, the council's approval of the development faces a referendum vote in May, a referendum that the developers are fighting in court to prevent.
The town itself has only two wells, a water source that barely provides for the existing population. The impact of such a massive development on the national park itself is even more worrisome.
... it pushes up against the limits of what we can provide,” said David Uberuaga, the superintendent of Grand Canyon National Park. “Everything is getting maxed out. They’re just doing it for the almighty dollar. It’s a gold mine they’re trying to exploit.”
It's schemes like this that turn me against the wave of support for "libertarianism," at least libertarianism in its purist form and taken to its logical conclusion.
Ron Paul, as Wikipedia notes, is "a free-market environmentalist, he asserts private property rights in relation to environmental protection and pollution prevention." According to the SourceWatch wikipedia:
Paul's stand on the environment is well-known. He is for the dissolution of the EPA, FDA, Department of the Interior and other government agencies whose overt mission is to protect citizens and the environment. Paul has also called for the privatizing of the National Park system .... Republicans for Environmental Protection gave him a score of 17 out of 100.
Libertarians, at least in their purist form, believe that property rights are absolute, and that every landowner has the absolute right to use his land as he pleases. They ignore what economists call externalities -- the fact that using your land as you please may impose costs on neighboring landowners and on the public in general.
Just as a steel mill built in downtown Beverly Hills would cause an enormous decrease in property values for miles around, so a 3 million square foot mega-mall on the border of Grand Canyon National Park may well destroy or damage the values for which the park was created, values that visitors travel from all over the world to experience.
This doesn't mean that nothing should ever be built within five miles of a national park. It does mean that values are at stake in addition to the developer's right to develop the property that he has acquired for development. Those values include the integrity of the neighboring national park, as well as the effects on residents of the small town itself in which the project is to be constructed.
Various land use regulatory agencies -- at the city or town, county, state and federal level -- protect these interests. The process for gaining regulatory approvals may seem cumbersome, and at times could well be improved. But libertarianism would strike down all regulatory protection for the public, and leave national parks and other environmental treasures to the mercy of developers and the free market.
We're not that kind of country. Nor should we be.
Posted by
Rainier96
at
2:30 PM
0
comments
Thursday, February 9, 2012
My cats drive me nuts!
The text used in my college survey course in psychology included a series of amazing paintings by Louis Wain, an early twentieth century painter afflicted with schizophrenia. Wain's paintings of cats became increasingly abstract and even frightening over time, as his symptoms worsened. My psych text offered the paintings, presumably, as an illustration of how the mental illness may affect the perceptions of its victim.
I found the paintings interesting for that reason, as well as aesthetically pleasing, and I've had them posted on this blog's sidebar almost since its inception. (I've always expected someone to ask some pointed questions about why I seemed so interested in madness, but, of course, no one ever did.)
It never occurred to me that the subject matter of the paintings -- cats -- had any relation to Wain's mental illness. Not until today, when I read an article in this month's Atlantic.1
If you spend much time around your cat's litter box, you've probably been exposed to a parasite found in cat feces called Toxoplasma gondii. T. gondii can be found in about 20 percent of Americans, and is known to be a health hazard to people with weakened immune systems. In healthy individuals, however, it causes at most mild flu symptoms before the parasite is overcome by the body's defenses and ends up dormant in the brain. This has been scientists' common understanding for many years.
But a Czech scientist named Jaroslav Flegr has discovered evidence that the parasite, rather than being dormant, works silently in the brain, rewiring connections in a way that affects the host's behavior. The purpose of this rewiring is to make the usual post-feline hosts, rats and mice, act in a way that will result in their being easily killed and eaten by another cat. For example, the "rewired" rodent becomes sexually attracted to the odor of cat urine, a response called "fatal feline attraction." When the cat eats the rodent, it also ingests the T. gondii that infects the rodent. The parasite finds itself cozily back in a feline environment, which happens to be the only environment in which it can reproduce. T. gondii has no interest in humans as such, and any effect by the parasite on human behavior would be inadvertent from an evolutionary standpoint.
But such behavioral effects do exist, Flegr has shown. For most of us, the effects are minor. Infected males, for example, tend statistically to become a bit more introverted, suspicious, uncaring about others' feelings, and inclined to ignore rules. (No, I'm not going to try drawing political conclusions!). But for persons who are genetically so inclined, Flegr believes, the parasite may also trigger the onset of schizophrenia.
Interestingly enough, so far as we know schizophrenia did not seem to exist until the late 1700's -- which is also the time when large numbers of urban Europeans began keeping cats as pets. And recent studies have shown that schizophrenia is two to three times as prevalent in persons infected with T. gondii parasites as in those who are not.
My cats and I watch each other, as we always have, with mutual curiosity. My own curiosity, however, is now tinged with surges of suspicion. Are my furry friends responsible for those psychedelic nightmares I seem to have at times? Do they explain the voices outside my window -- the ones just barely intelligible, but who seem to utter my name with contempt? I shudder. I feel increasingly introverted, as I regard Loki and Muldoon with a newly critical eye -- and with less concern for their own feline feelings than in the past.
The article does have reassuring things to say, I have to add, and I recommend its perusal to my own readership. I certainly suggest you read it before you drown your own cats, or before signing yourself into a mental hospital.
Still, one might as well be prudent ....
---------------------------------
1 Kathleen McAuliffe, "How Your Cat is Making You Crazy" (The Atlantic, March 2012)
Posted by
Rainier96
at
7:37 PM
0
comments
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Free the Malvinas?
I haven't offended a large nation for some time, so how about firing a shot over Argentina's bow? What's with all this latest news about Argentina and the Falkland Islands?
I don't have any strong feelings about the Falklands (or the Malvinas, as the Argentinians call them), but -- with all the various crises threatening world peace -- this seems like a strange time to heat up a strange issue.
At least, this time around, Argentina is simply filing a protest with the United Nations regarding the status of the British colony -- not attempting a sudden invasion as it did in 1982. The Argentine government also is reported to be contemplating banning (again) LAN Chile's weekly flight, over Argentina territory, between the Falklands and Chile -- the only regularly scheduled commercial flight to the Falklands, and a flight that carries food as well as passengers.
Despite the fact that the Falklands have been under British rule since 1833, and that all 2,500 inhabitants are English-speaking British subjects --70 percent of them being of British descent, with most of the others descended from French, Portuguese, Chilean, and Scandinavian immigrants -- the Argentinians continue to claim the islands as their own. Their claim is based primarily, it seems, on the fact that the Falklands are only 288 miles from the South America mainland, together with claims of British shenanigans before 1833.
The British say that the colony will remain British until the inhabitants vote otherwise. The British offered to submit the dispute to the International Court of Justice in 1947, but the Argentinians refused the offer.
While colonization ia generally agreed to be a bad thing, turning a close-knit community over to a foreign country that speaks a different language and possesses a radically different culture also seems a questionable practice.
If Argentina somehow succeeds, I think Canada should immediately demand title to St-Pierre and Miquelon -- a far smaller (93 sq. mi. v. 4,700 sq. mi.) French territory located just 15 miles off the coast of Newfoundland. The six thousand inhabitants speak French and happily conduct their business using the euro, rather than the dollar. But they're much closer to Canada than the Falklands are to Argentina, and if propinquity is the key, they should be Canadian. Unlike the Falklands controversy, with its linguistic difficulties, lots of Canadians speak French. In fact, the erstwhile French islands could be united with Québec. So what if they like being French? They'd grow to love being Québécois.
It's strange that Canada allows the sore of St-Pierre and Miquelon to fester just 15 miles off its coast. Maybe Canadians are sufficiently self-confident to consider the islands a tourist attraction rather than an affront to their sovereignty.
The present rumblings from Buenos Aires seems to have more to do with Argentine internal politics -- Americans know how that affects foreign policy, right? -- than it does with any immediate plan to seize the Falklands. Apparently, "freedom" for the "Malvinas" is the one issue on which all Argentinians can agree.
Let's hope that this time, it goes no further, and that Argentinians can satisfy their national pride sufficiently by their prowess on the soccer field.
Posted by
Rainier96
at
10:54 AM
0
comments
Saturday, February 4, 2012
Music frozen in amber
Despite frequently expressed concerns that "classical music" is a dying art form, in many ways, listeners have never had it so good. Not only is music performed live by orchestras and artists in virtually every city of any size, but a large number of interpretations of any given piece are available on CD (and vinyl).
Even those of us with the tinniest of ears appreciate that music heard in a concert hall differs from music heard at home on a sound system. Recorded music offers the closest the artist can come to perfection, albeit filtered through an electronic medium; live performance is more spontaneous, and the music may not be free from the performer's small errors or questionable judgments.
How does a musical piece get recorded and packaged for a CD? That's the question that pianist Jeremy Denk addresses in a witty and very well written article in this week's New Yorker. I've heard Denk play a number of times with chamber groups in Seattle. He's a fine pianist, and plays with odd postures and facial expressions that have become -- in my mind, at least -- his trademark. It's a pleasure to see past the guy at the piano to the man worrying about how his playing will sound once it's recorded.
Denk's writing reveals much of himself -- as does his playing itself, I'm sure, to those who know how to listen.
When I go home to visit my parents, my father has his stereo on all day. Surrounded by my junior-high-school spelling and typing trophies, I stew in my room, thinking of all the hours and tears that went into his musical wallpaper. I remember my parents hounding me to practice continuously, with the best intentions but without having to practice themselves. I fall prey to childish resentment: has my dad really earned the music that fills his house?
And he suspects that these recordings to which his dad listens, electronically tuned to perfection, aren't the real thing.
They're manicured artifacts, from which the essential spectacle of human effort has been clipped away.
But then Denk's manager asks him to prepare his own "manicured artifact," to record his interpretation of Charles Ives's "Concord" sonata. And so he shares his experience with us.
The first lesson he teaches is that the artist doesn't just sit down at a piano in front of a mike, flex his fingers, and let 'er rip. Instead, he plays each individual section of the sonata numerous times, varying his interpretations; the final recording is to be a composite of the best sections drawn from many playings. Then, Denk sits down with the sound engineer and listens to what he has played.
Every piano sounds different. Every individual microphone has different characteristics. The distance of each microphone from the piano, the angle at which it's oriented -- all these factors affect the sound that's actually recorded. Even when perfection in the instrument and recording devices seems achieved, the artist feels frustrated:
The most maddening paradox of recording is that what you hear in the playback does not resemble what you're sure you played. You hear two tracks at once: what you desire and what you have produced.
Denk and his engineer work their way, section by section, through the sonata, trying to match the recorded track to the ideal track in Denk's head.
He realizes, as he works, that technical perfection may not even be the proper goal. For example, slight misalignments in the piano's works, where the damper touches the string after each note, can result in what Denk calls an "aural schmear." He works with his engineer to remove all of these imperfections, only to discover that, once they're finished, they have somehow lessened the quality of the listening experience.
Eventually he [the engineer] plays me a schmear-free version. He looks so proud and satisfied that I can't bear to tell him that the result seems somehow sanitized. It's as if the reality of the piano had evaporated. I miss the schmear.
In the end, Denk, with the assistance of his engineer, pieces together relatively perfect segments of the sonata, recorded at different times, into a seamless whole -- resulting in an overall performance more perfect than any musician could achieve in a live concert.
And yet, the perfection achieved is never absolute. And it's in this lack of perfection that Denk actually finds relief -- there will always be something finer to which he can aspire.
No matter how wild the performance, something about the "Concord" always needs even more. I pressed eject on my stereo, thinking, No, you haven't made me redundant just yet. ... I realized that I couldn't wait for the next performance, when I would do it completely differently.
For me, for whom even the most familiar sonata contains subtleties that I can't even understand, let alone sense while listening, it's both humbling and inspiring to realize that a sonata is imbued with so much depth, with such complexity, that I could spend a lifetime simply listening to -- forget about playing -- the sonata and never exhaust what it has to teach me.
As for Jeremy Denk -- he's happy to realize that however perfectly recorded may be the music his dad hears on his stereo, it doesn't compete with the music he plays in live concerts. The near perfection of a studio recording and the spontaneity and "reality" of a live performance: each has its place, and Denk favors us with both.
Posted by
Rainier96
at
12:53 PM
0
comments
Thursday, February 2, 2012
One girl's struggle
Somehow, I consider it a matter of pride to have no idea of what's going on in popular culture. But occasionally, popular culture sneaks up and bites me on the butt before I recognize it.
Thus, a week ago, following a helpful prompt from Amazon, I began reading The Hunger Games, a "young adult" (read, "for teenagers") fantasy trilogy that I suppose appealed to the only semi-dormant sci-fi passions of my youth. Only after availing myself of Amazon's all-too-easy "one click" purchase protocol did I discover that I wasn't alone -- not only is the trilogy extremely popular, but its release as a film in March promises to be one of the cinematic events of the year.
Today, the Yahoo! homepage contains a prominant link to one of several YouTube trailers for the movie -- a link presented not as advertisement, but as "news."
So be it. I'll mingle with the masses, or at least the younger contingent of the masses. I was up late last night, my eyes glued to my Kindle, and am now 70 percent of my way through Catching Fire, the second of the three books.
The story, for those of you who, like me a week ago, haven't a clue, takes place in a post-apocalyptic future. All the wealth now belongs to the citizens of the "Capitol," an affluent and technologically advanced city apparently located somewhere near present day Denver. Today's U.S. has been divided into twelve impoverished districts, each ruled with an iron hand by the wealthy Capitol, each responsible for producing raw materials and goods for the Capitol citizenry. (See any political allegories, students?)
To demonstrate its absolute control, and to punish the citizens for a failed revolt 75 years earlier, each district is required annually to furnish a boy and a girl, selected by lottery, to take part in the Hunger Games -- a no-holds-barred combination of survival game and deadly combat, fought out in a huge wilderness "Arena", until only one out of the 24 kids is left alive. The games are unscripted but fully televised, in a manner well known to followers of our own "reality" shows.
The author is Suzanne Collins -- atypically for such dystopian fantasies, a woman -- and the story is told from the point of view of Katniss, a tough-minded girl of 16. The story is, as you'd expect, full of struggle, killings, anguish, torture, and physical hardship. But -- and I try not to think in stereotypes -- the story seems to reveal the gender of both the author and her protagonist by simultaneously focusing on Katniss's complex and ever-changing relationships (friends? enemies? rivals? lovers?) with two boys, one of whom is a childhood friend back home and the other, her fellow representative from District 12.
The books also seem to focus at times to a weird degree on fashion, cosmetics, and food preparation. This focus could be another indication of femininity, but more likely is simply a device to contrast the effete superficiality of the "One Percent" (my term) who live frivolous, meaningless lives in the Capitol with the tough, quick minds and even tougher bodies of the youngsters from the districts, kids who have grown up familiar with hunger, poverty, and hardship, but have also learned to adapt and think quickly.
The games are played against long-smoldering opposition to the Capitol by the oppressed masses. Katniss's television persona appears both a precipitating factor pushing the districts to active revolt, and a beacon of hope for the rebels.
Having sneaked a look at Amazon reviews for the third book, Mockingjay, I realize that some weird things are waiting in my reading future. Roughly half of the readers appear anguished at the way the plot develops in the final book, and with the unhappy resolution for Katniss and all the people for whom readers had grown attached.
The other half of the reviewers essentially say, "That's life and that's war, toots. Learn to live with it." They loved the ending.
So, my attention will be absorbed a few more days while Katniss discovers and faces her Fate. Then my blog can return to its usual urbane fascination with post-modernist deconstruction of Elizabethan drama.
Posted by
Rainier96
at
11:08 AM
0
comments
Saturday, January 28, 2012
Liberal education
"From our perspective, liberal education is not some roster of required courses to round out the major, but the totality of our students' education," he said. "It encompasses all four years and embraces not only curricula – breadth requirements and courses in the major – but also dorm life, overseas studies, community-based service, and student experiences in laboratories, on athletic fields, in internships and in student groups – all of the places where our students learn and grow."
--Quoting Prof. James T. Campbell (committee co-chairman)
It's a cliché, but young people are the future of our country. The corollary: Their education is one of society's most critical responsibilities.
Therefore, I've been interested enough to at least skim through the 100-page printed report that Stanford released on Thursday, a report analyzing the future of undergraduate education at that school. The report reviews the history of similar past studies and the results of their implementation, and sets forth guidelines for the future.
Stanford has had its share of curriculum battles in the past. The report notes that fact, and attempts to skirt some of those minefields by identifying abilities, and only to a lesser extent the substantitive knowledge, that it believes all college graduates should possess.
Foremost is the ability to communicate effectively -- writing clearly, reading closely and critically, speaking effectively, and listening attentively to the opinions of others, especially when those opinions challenge the student's own most closely held beliefs.
Other abilities listed are critical thinking, aesthetic and interpretive judgment, formal and quantitative reasoning, ability to think historically, facility with scientific analysis, and a "rich capacity for creative expression," in whatever field the student is working.
Stating these goals is easy; how they might be implemented occupies the bulk of the report. The report acknowledges the apparent tug of war between specialization in a major and the breadth of learning required by a liberal education. The writers feel that, rightly conceived, the tug of war is illusory: each complements and strengthens the other.
Most interesting, from my perspective, is the emphasis that the report gives to education beyond the classroom -- in student residences, on overseas campuses, and through engagement in off-campus learning experiences (internships, field studies, performing arts, and, especially, community service programs).
At Stanford, as at many other residential schools located outside of large cities, 98 percent of the undergraduates live in university housing. Life in dormitories provides strong opportunities -- not always fully realized -- to encourage learning in various ways apart from the formal curriculum. When I was an undergraduate, I developed many of my own lasting interests simply from unstructured interactions with other students in my housing unit. But the report goes beyond these serendipitous opportunities, suggesting introduction of additional resident faculty members to live and dine with the students in their living groups, and greatly increased use of "integrated learning environments" where students with similar academic interests are clustered in the same unit for a year.
Living in dorms, students grapple intimately with the meanings of citizenship, leadership, diversity, respect, tolerance, and community, developing capacities that are not only intellectual but also social and emotional. The goal of residential education is not to “academicize” these experiences, but to create opportunities for students to connect their curricular and residential lives, in ways that enrich both.
Every university does studies of this sort periodically. The goals are never perfectly realized. But it's important that faculty and administrators sit down occasionally and ask "what is it we're hoping to accomplish, and what tools do we have to improve out performance." This report seems well thought out -- both in terms of educational objectives and in the means it suggests for accomplishing those objectives.
The Stanford report is of value not only to students and faculty at that school, but also to us, the general public. Reading it reminds me of the importance of education; of the excitement that the availability of appropriate educational tools helps generate in both students and faculty; and, simply, how much fun, as well as hard work, the pursuit of learning -- structured and not so structured -- can be.
And ... let's face it. Reading this report also makes me wish I could go back and do it all over again -- all the anxieties and uncertainties, the deadlines, the term papers and final exams -- and the living from day to day on excessive levels of caffeine -- notwithstanding.
Posted by
Rainier96
at
12:59 PM
0
comments
Monday, January 23, 2012
A dervish in Milwaukee
And Allah said: I am with the ones
whose hearts are torn.
--Hadith Qudsi
The test of a first rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposing ideas in the mind at the same time and still retain the ability to function.
--F. Scott Fitzgerald
Ayad Akhtar's novel, American Dervish, begins with a prologue: Hayat, a Pakistani-American college student, is eating his first pork at a basketball game and exulting over his new freedom from the claims of religious faith. The novel then flashes back to Hayat's boyhood, his memories as a 12-year-old, living with his immigrant, but well-off, family in suburban Milwaukee.
I began reading with the expectation that Akhtar was about to give us a Muslim counterpart to Joyce's Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man. And, indeed, like Joyce's autobiographical novel, American Dervish is a story of an adolescent boy who, after a period of being deeply devout, becomes disillusioned with his faith. Also, like Joyce, Akhtar reveals the beauty and wisdom of that faith, as perceived by the youth, as well as how religious belief can be used to narrow rather than open the mind of a sensitive and intelligent child.
But where Portrait of the Artist is almost solipsistic in the narrator's focus upon himself, American Dervish's primary focus returns repeatedly to an older woman: Mina, the best friend of Hayat's mother, whom the boy calls his aunt.
Hayat's family does not fit easily into the local Pakistani community. His father is a physician, an unbeliever, and an irritable but loving father. His mother has little interest in religion as such, but clings to the traditions of Islam out of homesickness for the Pakistani Punjab. Hayat himself is a quiet boy, but initially seems totally American -- Midwestern and suburban in his life and interests.
But then, when he is 12, Aunt Mina, a strikingly beautiful woman escaping an abusive arranged marriage, arrives from Pakistan to live with Hayat's family. Mina reveals to Hayat the beauties of Islam, teaches him to pray, teaches him to memorize the Quran. Without understanding his own feelings, Hayat falls in love. Romantic love for an "aunt" clearly being impossible, he instead throws himself into her love of Islam. He abandons former pasttimes, spending all his free time memorizing verses.
"Almighty God," Muhammad said, "let me see you."
And all at once, he saw nothing but the Lord. He looked to the right and saw nothing but the Lord. He looked to the left and saw nothing but the Lord, and to the front, and the back, and above...and everywhere he looked, he saw nothing but the Lord. What the Lord looked like Muhammad would never say, other than that His beauty was so great he would have preferred to stand there gazing at Him forever.
But Mina is unlike other members of the local Pakistani community, Muslims whom Hayat's father contemptuously describes as "sheep." She is intelligent, cosmopolitan, and delights in the freedom of American society. She contantly reminds Hayat that forms of worship aren't important to God, what's important are the intentions of his heart. Memorization of the Quran -- which he's told would guarantee his parents' admission to Heaven -- is worthless if he doesn't understand what he is memorizing. Mina is greatly influenced by the Sufi dervishes, mystics whose orthodoxy conservative Muslims have always considered suspect, holy men who seek to surrender everything that might separate them from God's love.
What the dervish found was true humility. He realized that he was no better, no worse than the ground itself, the ground that takes the discarded orange peels of the world. In fact, he realized he was the same as that ground, the same as those peels, as those men, as everything else. He was the same as everything created by Allah's hand. ... He and Allah, and everything Allah created, it was all One.
Much of the novel's plot describes how Hayat, in his frantic possessive love for Mina, sabotages her engagement with Nathan, a Jewish doctor and his father's partner, forcing her unexpectedly into a marriage with a more "suitable" local Pakistani -- a man so insecure that he spends his life locking her away from all other people and physically abusing her.
Mina dies of cancer, after years of abuse, a woman crushed in both mind and body by events she could not control -- and events for which Hayat feels intense guilt. Shortly before Mina's death, Hayat visits her in the hospital -- where he finds her delighting in the Scott Fitzgerald quotation she'd found in his published letters -- and confesses how he ruined her life. She told him it was God's will:
Faith has never been about an afterlife for me, Hayat. It's about finding God now. In the everyday. Here. With you. Whether I'm living in a prison or in a castle. Sick or healthy. It's all the same. That's what the Sufis teach. ... Every single life, no matter how big or small, how happy or how sad, it can be a path to Him.
Hayat can't agree, can't understand the hold Sufi thought has always had on her. She replies that her pain is how God speaks through her.
"[E]verything, everything, is an expression of Allah's will. It is all His glory. Even the pain ..." She paused. "That is the real truth about life."
In an Epilogue, Hayat, years later and now a college graduate working in Boston as an intern for the Atlantic, runs into Nathan in Harvard Square. The doctor had stayed in touch by mail with Mina, clandestinely, and knew her story. He brushes off Hayat's attempts at apology, kindly, and essentially gives him the forgiveness that he needs.
Hayat walks away from that encounter, strolling along the Charles river, feeling alive and filled with an odd gratitude. He remembers, for the first time in ten years, verses from the Quran he had memorized back when he was a devout boy of 12:
Truly with hardship comes ease.
With hardship comes ease!
And so when you are finished, do not rest,
But return to your Lord with love...
Posted by
Rainier96
at
10:12 AM
0
comments
Wednesday, January 18, 2012
Struggles in Ireland
Out of Ireland have we come.
Great hatred, little room,
Maimed us at the start.
I carry from my mother's womb
A fanatic heart.
--W. B. Yeats
Today, Seattle is immobilized by one of our rare great snowfalls. But last night, the sidewalks were still clear enough for me to walk 1½ miles to the UW campus to attend the first of a three part lecture series entitled "Revenge and Reconciliation in Modern Ireland." The cold and snow outside the hall served as an appropriate metaphor for the hunger and bleakness of so much of Irish history.
The lecturer, Prof. George K. Behlmer of the University history department, discussed in a fast-paced two hours the period from the Rebellion of 1789 up to the end of the nineteenth century. He argued that nothing inherent in the Irish character predisposes them to violence, and that the Irish have suffered from a poor image -- both as harbored within themselves and as revealed to the world at large -- an image of self-loathing, tendency to violence, and adherence to an improbable national mythology, an image that is, to a large degree, one of its own creation. Ireland's greatest writers, such as Yeats and Joyce, have, in their writings, certainly contributed to this image.
Dr. Behlmer discussed specifically the short lives and careers of three Irish revolutionaries -- all, interestingly, themselves Protestant -- Theobald Wolfe Tone (1763-98), Thomas Davis (1814-45), and Charles Parnell (1846-91), and how each had attempted to develop a sense of Irish identity apart from Britain, and to secure independence or -- at least in Parnell's case -- home rule for Ireland.
The speaker also discussed Ireland's greatest socio-economic crisis of the nineteenth century, the so-called Potato Famine of 1845-50. Ireland, already overpopulated relative to its resources, lost 5/8 of its population to starvation, disease, and emigration. But Behlmer -- though challenged by audience members following the lecture -- disagreed with Irish contentions that Britain's response to the famine -- a natural disaster resulting directly from rapid spread of a potato plant blight -- constituted "genocide."
Britain's prime minister in 1845, Sir Robert Peel, made attempts to alleviate starvation in Ireland, which included forcing through Parliament the bitterly resisted repeal of the protectionist Corn Laws. Despite Peel's efforts (which contributed to the fall of his government), Behlmer suggested that the overall climate of the times was opposed to any intervention in the economic realm that might have alleviated Irish suffering more directly -- an early display of "libertarian" philosophy, I suppose. Beginning in 1846, under the Whig ministry that followed the fall of the Peel government, the Irish were left to the mercies of the laws of supply and demand.
If genocide denotes the deliberate killing of a national group, then the British were not guilty of genocide; the sentiment in Parliament at the time was simply to allow the natural laws of economics to work themselves out. Which reminds us of the "modernization" of the ten commandments by Arthur Hugh Clough:
Thou shalt not kill; but need'st not strive
Officiously to keep alive ...
Professor Behlmer's first lecture brought to life the brutal hardships and suffering -- the results of both natural causes and British rule -- from which Ireland suffered in the nineteenth century. Whether these hardships affected the way that Irish children were reared -- making the Irish inclined to violence from early childhood, bearing within themselves Yeats's "fanatic heart" -- remains, for me at least, a question for further exploration in the succeeding two lectures.
Posted by
Rainier96
at
11:24 AM
0
comments
Saturday, January 14, 2012
Triumph for Robert Bruce?
You can't hike through Scotland, I discovered last summer, without learning to love the Scots. But I do have to admit that, for the casual two-week hiker like myself, it's difficult to distinguish the Scots from the English. Aside from the fact that the Scots speak English that's easier to understand than that spoken by the English themselves. (The Gaelic? Um, let's not talk about that.)
All the more reason to be mildly suprised that the Scottish independence movement seems to be moving ahead full steam. A referendum on independence will be held in 2014, although there's a bit of a tussle as to whether the referendum will be drafted and scheduled by the British government in London, or by the Scottish "devolved" government in Edinburgh.
Why independence? Various economic and cultural rationales are put forth, but the real reason seems to be that the Scots have never got over the sense of being oppressed by the English, both before and after the two kingdoms were united in 1707. (James VI of Scotland had ruled that country for 36 years before also becoming James I of England in 1606, but the two nations weren't formally united for another century.1) Little incidents like the Massacre of Glencoe, discussed with such relish in this blog last summer, seem to have left a bad taste in a sizable number of contemporary Scottish mouths.
"I'd have a brick wall across the border," the Associated Press reported a Scots woman as exclaiming. At least it's a shorter border than that running from Tijuana to the Rio Grande.
Europe's a funny place. Wonderful, but funny. The trend since World War II has been clearly centripetal -- from the European Coal and Steel Community of the 1940's, to the six-nation European Economic Community in 1958, to the ever-growing and ever more centralized European Community of today -- reinforced by the Schengen agreement, eliminating passport controls between signatory nations, and the Euro zone, adopting the euro as a common currency.
The independence and borders of individual nations in Europe seem increasingly irrelevant, at least to the outsider. But national sensitivities obviously still set emotional chords vibrating within various European countries. Scotland seeks independence from England. The Flemish and Walloons hardly speak to each other, leaving the future of Belgium in doubt. The Basques want to break away from Spain, and the Catalans are, at minimum, a bit touchy. North and south Italy are virtually two different states already. Greece won't even allow the Macedonians to call themselves Macedonians. And Kosovo? Let's not go there.
As the government in Brussels becomes ever more powerful -- which it will, despite current economic problems -- I suppose it's become safer for the constitutent countries to indulge themselves by working out some of their old disputes under the EC umbrella. If it were still every European nation for itself, with a credible external threat from, say, Russia, or from a newly aggressive Germany, Scotland might not be quite so eager to shed its partnership in the United Kingdom.
Separatism in Europe reinspires my own dreams for that long mooted breakaway nation of Cascadia -- a federal union of Oregon, Washington and British Columbia. It will never happen, of course. The world would not tolerate a single country's existing with such a monopoly of rational, liberal thought and politics; extraordinary natural beauty; economic self-suffiency; superlative education and literacy; and widespread human warmth and friendliness among its citizens. Such a star -- a supernova, really -- would so dazzle the eye as to render all other stars in the firmament next to invisible.
The world couldn't handle it. Meanwhile, however, best wishes to our friends in Scotland and England. We love both your countries, jointly and severally, and hope everything works out amicably between you.
--------------------------------
Posted by
Rainier96
at
1:43 PM
0
comments
Friday, January 13, 2012
Crippling the leader
South Carolina has picked the Republican nominee in every primary since the Reagan era began in 1980. It will do so again this year. So we were told by the chairman of the UW Communications (journalism) Department on Wednesday night, in the first of a series of five lectures analyzing the 2012 election campaign.
If so, Mitt Romney's looking good. As of now, at least, he seems to be the obvious front-runner in South Carolina. He also appears to be the best hope for the Republicans in the general election -- a conservative who doesn't make the hair of 70 percent of the voters stand on end, one who can perhaps beguile many moderates and independents into casting their votes for him.
The wild card in South Carolina, however, is a specter from past electoral wars - Newt Gingrich. With millions of dollars in a Super PAC fund, Newt has launched a $3.5 million advertising campaign designed specifically to destroy Romney's viability as a candidate.
By all accounts, the television advertising is devastatingly negative. As Krystal Ball [sic] writes on The Atlantic's website:
Newt hopes to scream at the general election voter that Mitt is such an unbelievably heartless, cold, greedy person that the party that calls ketchup a vegetable and wants to throw people off unemployment during the worst recession since the Great Depression finds him heartless.
Ball labels this advertising barrage as "The Newtron Bomb." She suggests that only Newt Gingrich could get away with such vilification -- any Democrat who made the same arguments would be pilloried as vicious, unfair, and mean-spirited.
Newt's advertising is designed to persuade South Carolina voters that Mitt would be unelectable if nominated; in the process, he may in fact be making him exactly that. Why would Newt -- whose hopes for the nomination must seem remote, even to himself -- do everything possible to cripple the party's front runner? Ball has an answer to that question as well -- Newt's motive is not the good of the country or the success of the Republican party. His motive is, simply, personal revenge.
Early on, Gingrich asked Romney to agree to a campaign free of negative ads. Romney declined. Gingrich got burned by Romney's negative advertising. Gingrich's hostility is now implacable.
A Gingrich TV commercial made available today ties Romney to other Massachusetts public figures -- ones presumably not popular in the Palmetto State. Most devastating of all, the commercial shows clips of both former Democratic candidate John Kerry and Mitt Romney speaking in French. The voice over: "And just like John Kerry -- he speaks French, too." How elitest can a candidate get? How appalling is fluency in French by a presidential candidate in this year of Republican populism?
As a Democratic partisan, I have to admit to a certain pleasure in watching the opposition tear itself apart for as long as possible, and especially in watching Republican attempts to destroy their most potentially successful nominee. On the other hand, it's frightening to watch one of our two major parties systematically eliminate every presidential candidate with any sense of moderation, sophistication, and complexity of thought. After all, the Republicans might always win, even with a pathetic candidate, if the economy stays bad. The normal tendency of the American voter is to blame discontent with the nation's direction on whichever party happens to occupy the White House.
Thus Nixon won in 1968, in voter reaction to the "hippie movement" and anti-war demonstrations. And we all know how that turned out.
"Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose," as Newt Gingrich would never say. Let's hope history does not repeat itself -- not this time.
Posted by
Rainier96
at
12:39 PM
0
comments
Wednesday, January 11, 2012
Indiana boy
Back in 1995, while browsing through magazines at Barnes & Noble, my eye was caught by a magazine I'd never seen before called Strings. On the cover was what appeared to be a teenaged violinist. Not only the cover article (actually, a lengthy, in-depth interview), but the entire magazine looked interesting, and so I bought a copy. Which I still own.
The violinist was not a teenager, however. He was a young man of 27 by the name of Joshua Bell. Today, Bell is perhaps the best known violinist in the United States, if not the world. Last night, I heard him in concert for the second time in my life, this time playing the Bruch Violin Concerto with the Seattle Symphony.
The Strings article noted:
The identifying traits of Bell's playing are a honeyed yet not overly viscous tone, uncompromising beauty of sound without a favoring of tone quality over musical rhetoric, a keen attention to local detail within a firm sense of overall musical architecture ...
I'm no music critic, obviously, but insofar as I can judge, these remain his characterists today, and were well displayed in his performance of the lush, hyper-Romantic Bruch concerto.
In his Strings interview, Bell sounded American in a way that no performer born in Europe could ever sound. He grew up a Hoosier, the son of an Indiana University professor. He was a fan of tennis and basketball. He rambled on for a paragraph, extolling the joys of golf, which he claimed was "really more than a sport -- it's almost Zenlike, the focus in every shot." And he proudly admitted to ranking fourth in the nation in a computer pinball simulation called Crystal Caliburn. He said he was eager to beat the No. 1 score "which is by some guy from Eugene, Oregon."
Last night, Bell walked onto the stage, dressed informally in black, a mop of dark hair falling down his forehead, and greeted the audience with a seemingly shy smirk. He was called back by thunderous applause for approximately seven bows before finally returning with his violin to play a solo encore. I didn't catch the name of the encore selection, but it was a short piece, well post-Romantic, that revealed the many sounds that Bell can generate from a violin -- and the speedy tempo at which he is capable of bowing.
Joshua Bell is now 44. He's the father of a four-year-old son, but still looks like a kid from Indiana himself. His name is known to anyone with the slightest interest in symphonic music.1 Since 1995, I've collected most of the CD's featuring his playing, including all of the major violin concertos. Despite obvious sophistication, he still looks like a guy who, when he gets the time, shoots a few hoops and challenges a few unsuspecting victims to on-line pinball. And probably lets out a whoop when he wins.
One post a year about a concert is probably all most readers can tolerate. My apologies for two of them in one week, but last night's concert was an exceptional event.
--------------------------
Posted by
Rainier96
at
10:26 AM
0
comments
Monday, January 9, 2012
Peeping early from its bower
Thy smiles I note, sweet early Flower,
That peeping from thy rustic bower
The festive news to earth dost bring,
A fragrant messenger of Spring.
--Coleridge, "To a Primrose"
"Sweet early flower," indeed. The primrose each year is one of the earliest of blooms. Its English name itself means "first rose." (Its Latin name, less poetically, is Primula vulgaris.)
A few primroses dwell in my front yard, resident there since time immemorial. They make their usual appearance in early to mid February, providing me the first reassurance that winter lasts not forever -- that the sun already hasteneth his way northwards. That Spring is on her way.
Today is only January 9, and yet my young primroses already are in bloom. Three flowers fully open: deep purple with yellow centers. Three more peeping forth as purple buds, flowers inchoate. Mine are Primula vulgaris sibthorpii (native to the Balkans and southwest Asia), distinguished by their purple color from the yellow and, well, more vulgar Primula vulgaris vulgaris (native to western and southern Europe). Like Iowa and New Hampshire Republicans, in 2012 my primroses seem to have tripped all over themselves, in their impatient eagerness to rush the season.
Why so early? Mildness of weather? We haven't had many sub-freezing temperatures this year, but the weather's been otherwise -- as usual -- cold and wet. Have my primroses been prematurely aroused by the strength of the political winds? Or are my plants eager to stage one final show for my benefit, saddened with foreknowledge that this coming December brings to an end the Mayan world cycle?
Who knows what's in their pretty little heads? But their arrival is welcome. And if their arrival should augur an early end to winter, I'm all for it. I'm all for it, even should their appearance -- like melting glaciers and overheated polar bears -- be but additional evidence of global warming, that bête noir of my political adversaries.
The primrose was Prime Minister Disraeli's favorite flower. It is the county flower of Devon. It is edible. Its leaves can be used to make tea, and its flowers to make primrose wine. It's a loveable flower, and I do love it. I greet with warmth its early appearance.
Welcome again for yet another year, O Primula vulgaris . Bring us peace in our time, an early spring, and a Happy New Year.
Posted by
Rainier96
at
4:25 PM
0
comments
Sunday, January 8, 2012
Music from Trinity
I'd never heard of John Adams. No, not the president from Quincy, Massachusetts. I'm talking about the composer from Worcester, Massachusetts.
At least, I didn't think I'd ever heard of him until last night, but now I see that he's famous for his 1987 opera Nixon in China, which I guess I have heard of at one time or another. But certainly never seen.
Anyway, last night the Seattle Symphony concluded the evening's program with the Doctor Atomic Symphony, orchestral music adapted from John Adams's 2005 opera, Doctor Atomic. The program notes admonish me that Adams is "widely recognized as the pre-eminent American composer of his generation." So, there you are, my own ignorance notwithstanding.
Despite the extreme conservatism of my musical tastes, I found the symphony -- maybe more a tone poem than a symphony: a single movement, 23 minutes in length -- to be dramatic and gripping and worth my attention. The score was loud and dissonant and heavy on the percussion, as one would expect from a modern work, but also rich in melody in the woodwinds and brass. The conductor -- a visiting conductor from the St. Louis Symphony -- gave us a short and witty pre-performance synopsis of the opera's plot, and explained how the symphony tracks that plot and introduces the major musical themes of the opera.
The opera takes place in 1945 -- the first act occuring shortly before the testing of the first atomic bomb at Alamogordo, N.M., and the second act immediately before detonation of the Hiroshima bomb. The focus is on J. Robert Oppenheimer, the "father" of the atomic bomb, whose ambivalence about what he was creating -- and later, what he had created -- eventually led to the government's yanking of his security clearance.
Oppenheimer was a poet as well as a theoretical physicist. It was he who famously recalled his feelings while observing the initial bomb test in New Mexico with a line from the Bhagavad Gita: "Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds." He gave the code name of "Trinity" to the Alamogordo test site, after his favorite sonnet by John Donne: "Batter my heart, three-person'd God."
Oppenheimer, the "Dr. Atomic" of the opera's title, has always fascinated and impressed me. At one time, back when I had personal heroes, I guess I considered him as such.
The symphonic derivative of the opera that we heard last night combined breathtaking musical elements of fear, anticipation, and explosive violence, with an overall sense of poetry and awe. It was not "easy listening," compared with the Mozart piano concerto that had immediately preceded it, but it was moving and thought-provoking.
If the opportunity ever presents itself, I might actually persuade myself to attend John Adams's opera itself -- just out of curiosity and, perhaps, as my own personal tribute to the life of Dr. Oppenheimer.
Posted by
Rainier96
at
3:15 PM
0
comments


