Wednesday, August 31, 2011

Accepting uncertainty


The mass media rarely carry articles dealing with religion in a truly thoughtful manner. Insofar as they deal with religion at all, newspapers are more apt either to discuss sensational religious events ("Rapture didn't happen; we're all still here!), or to provide comfort to the religiously comfortable ("President lights up White House Christmas tree!").

Last week, however, USA Today ran an interesting feature article based on the thought of physicist and Anglican priest John Polkinghorne. Polkinghorne's work in the field of elementary particles led him to play a role in the discovery of quarks, and he has conducted advanced theoretical research in other areas.1 Theoretical mathematicians and physicists typically do their most important work by the age of 30. When Polkinghorne felt his best work had been done, he began studies for ordination to the priesthood.

But the USA Today article focused less on his unusual combination of vocations, and more upon his thoughts concerning doubt and uncertainty. No one has ever seen a quark, the article noted. We "believe" in them because their supposed existence is necessary to make sense of the empirical data. The existence of quarks has not been "proved." In fact, no scientific theory is ever proved -- including evolution, as fundamentalists like to point out. If new data suggest a better theoretical model, scientists of course reconsider their "beliefs."

Similarly, Polkinghorne points out, we don't have empirical evidence of God's existence. The traditional "proofs" offered for the existence of God suggest reasons to believe, but do not constitute mathematical or logical proofs.

In other contexts, Polkinghorne has pointed to scientific or cosmological evidence that make belief in God reasonable, or even compelling, but the evidence does not logically demand belief in God's existence.

As we go through life, we are constantly forced to believe or not believe in logically possible conclusions based on our judgment of the conflicting strengths of the evidence and the repercussions resulting from making the wrong judgment. If we don't "believe" in global warming and so ignore it, for example, what are the consequences of being wrong?

Polkinghorne says that, as a thinking person, he naturally considers the possibility that God and Christianity could be human inventions with no basis in reality.

"It's [i.e., belief in God] a reasonable position, but not a knock-down argument," he said. "It's strong enough to bet my life on it. Just as Polanyi2 bet his life on his belief, knowing that it might not be true, I give my life to it, but I'm not certain. Sometimes I'm wrong."

Quarks may be a fiction. Fossil evidence of dinosaurs may have been planted in the ground by a capricious God to lead prideful men to question Genesis. The universe, as I discussed in an earlier post, may have been a child's toy -- like a model train set -- cobbled together by a young super being, a toy that he left running after he went off to college. The world we observe by our senses may even be the dream of some Matrix-like pod people.

But based on the evidence known to him and on his life experiences, Polkinghorne has made a conscious decision to accept the existence of God and the message of Christianity, and to base his life on that decision. As Christian doctrine traditionally holds, belief in Christ would not be meritorious if it were forced on us by logic. Christian belief is not contrary to logic, but the merit adheres in our voluntary decision to assent to its message of love and to live our lives in accordance with that message.

Polkinghorne's own message goes beyond these age-old arguments between atheists and theists, however. If even devout Christians such as Polkinghorne are forced to admit the logical possibility of being wrong, how much more should those of us dealing with the more mundane, human questions of politics be willing to admit at all times that we know nothing with certainty, that our political and economic convictions are merely hopeful theories, and that we may well be thinking and acting in error.

Oliver Cromwell's exclamation to the Scottish church, "I beseech you, in the bowels of Christ, think it possible you may be mistaken," applies to all facets of life. John Polkinghorne, Ph.D., professor of mathematical physics at Cambridge, President of Queen's College (Cambridge), and Canon Theologian of Liverpool Cathedral has issued our world a call for intellectual and emotional humility, a reminder that there is little if anything in our universe about which we can claim absolute certainty.

------------------------
1He has "researched the analytic and high-energy properties of Feynman integrals and the foundations of S-Matrix theory," according to Wikipedia.

2"Michael Polanyi (March 11, 1891 – February 22, 1976) was a Hungarian–British polymath, who made important theoretical contributions to physical chemistry, economics, and the theory of knowledge. In his philosophical writings he argued that positivism not only gives a false account of the practice of science, it also, if taken seriously, undermines our highest achievements as human beings."
--Wikipedia

Sunday, August 28, 2011

Camp Muir


If you're looking for a day hike that will give you some of the most incredible views available in the Pacific Northwest, as well as fully test your endurance, head for Camp Muir.

Camp Muir is the staging point for 90 percent of the summit climbs of Mt. Rainier, including those run by the Park's official guide service. After struggling from the roadhead at Paradise (5,400 ft.) up to Camp Muir (10,080 ft.), carrying 40 pound packs, you "enjoy" a few hours of sleep on wooden shelves inside a crowded, noisy shelter, built in 1921 and never redecorated, before being roused at about 11 p.m. to begin the climb to the summit (14,411 ft.)

But Camp Muir itself makes a nice day hike destination. I gave it a try yesterday, partly for the scenery, partly to help condition myself for my Nepal trek in October.

As those of us in the Northwest Corner are all too aware, we had a heavy snow pack this past year, and -- until the last two or three weeks -- an unusually cool summer. As a result, even the labyrinth of paths that the Park Service provides for car tourists -- paved in asphalt and designed to let families wander up above Paradise Lodge without too much effort, giving them an opportunity to view the wild flowers and wildlife -- remain covered by snow fields in many places. These paths are usually free of snow by mid-July. But the snow fields on these lower slopes aren't steep, and have foot paths etched into them, so the tourists were still out in force. A major attraction this year, one that I've never noticed before in this area, was a large number of large and unintimidated marmots, rolling and frolicking about beside the trail like a bunch of playful kittens.

The paths become more ambitious and dedicated to leading hikers to specific destinations once you reach a couple hundred vertical feet above the Lodge. The highest point reachable by trail is Pebble Creek, at 7,200 feet. Once past the creek, you find yourself on the Muir snowfield, a massive, undulating field of year-round snow that continues unrelentingly upward, all the way to the buildings at Camp Muir. While the trail to Pebble Creek is fun to walk for a number of reasons, the snowfield beyond is simply a long, exhausting slog. You do it because you have to, if you're a summit climber, or, for hikers, because you've told yourself that Camp Muir shall be the day's destination. The scenery becomes ever more spectacular, of course, as you climb higher -- but I suspect that scenery watching and photography become for most hikers mainly excuses to catch one's breath. That was certainly true for me, at least.

After you hang out for a while at the Camp, scoping out the views and perhaps feeling somewhat envious of those who are there for the summit climb, there remains the descent. I had departed from Paradise somewhat later in the day than I'd intended, and didn't start down until after 4 p.m. The snow was starting to ice in places, which made the descent less carefree -- and slower -- than I had hoped. (A number of falls, painful only to my dignity.) Also, I was wearing shorts, which made seat-of-the-pants glissades, a popular activity in the steep areas, not really feasible. I envied a large group of Indian or Indian-American tourists who had brought plastic garbage bags with them for use as sleds. They were descending more swiftly, and with a lot more noisy fun, than was I.

But the scenery was magnificent on a bright sunny day, and the temperature was moderate so that the hiking was comfortable. I took a bunch of great photos. And my muscles and cardiovascular system certainly got the workout I'd hoped for. Four hours up, and two and a half hours down. A highly satisfying day.

Wednesday, August 24, 2011

Rubus fruticosus


When I moved to my present house, the city block on which it's located was essentially one large plantation of blackberries. Each back yard was a space carved out of this plantation -- space stolen from the domain of the Mother Bramble, if you will. Where many city blocks might have an alley, we on 26th Avenue were separated from the houses behind us on 25th by a tangle of blackberry vines, growing on lots facing both streets, a tangle that towered above us. The Mother Bramble also shot out extensions, like pseudopods, between adjacent lots as well, so that my backyard was protected on three sides by walls of barbed vines.

Fences make good neighbors, but we had no need for wooden fences. We had our blackberries. And our "fences," unlike those built of sterile cedar planks, produced fruit. Quite tasty fruit, especially about this time of year.

But change came to the 'hood. More and more upward-aspirational techies and professionals moved in. The alluring photos in Sunset magazine didn't show back yards surrounded by blackberry vines, and Sunset magazine (or some more upscale version thereof) was the garden bible for the new immigrants.

I've always regretted the felling of the great American forest by the pioneers and those who came after. Something similar happened around these parts, as homeowner after homeowner cut his way deeper and deeper into the blackberry jungle. I'm not entirely immune from peer pressure, although more immune, perhaps, than my neighbors would prefer. I, too, eventually hired workers to root out my blackberries, to sanitize my backyard, to show myself as a civilized man in a civiized neighborhood.

The blackberries were gone, but, like Adam and Eve after the Fall, we now felt ourselves naked. The fellow next door quickly hid himself from his neighbors by building a fence around his yard to replace the blackberry barriers. I countered his starkly utilitarian fence, shielding it from my view, by planting a laurel hedge. My yard now appears reasonably tidied up. Just like everyone else's.

I have met the enemy, and he be me.

But there's a postscript. Blackberries don't surrender gracefully. They may concede the battle, but not the war. In corners of my yard, they spring back to life whenever my back is turned. Before I really notice, they begin reasserting themselves with renewed vigor, claiming territory as theirs by right. Just as the medieval church discovered, the battle against heresy is never won, because heresy always raises its ugly head when vigilance is relaxed.

And like a new convert to orthodoxy, my horror at each reappearance of blackberry vines exceeds the bounds of reason. I've been inspecting my backyard each morning with pruning shears in hand, ready to cut down each timid blackberry sprout as it emerges from the soil. My strategy is psychological -- the hope that I can convince the blackberries that resistance is futile, that they will be utterly destroyed the moment they appear above ground.

Punishment does not take place primarily and per se for the correction and good of the person punished, but for the public good in order that others may become terrified and weaned away from the evils they would commit

as the 1578 handbook of the Inquisition so adroitly phrased it.

Soon, I shall have extirpated the species entirely from my domain, and will live in a totally domesticated and controlled environment, with only those plants authorized by the editors of Sunset growing in my closely watched soil. I have conquered not only the wiles of Rubus fruticosus , but also my own earlier weakness and unhealthy tolerance of heterodoxy.

I think I'll celebrate by going to Safeway and buying a $4.99 carton of blackberries to heap on my mornng cereal.

Monday, August 22, 2011

Kidnapped


Some people, after returning from a first trip to Hawaii, can't resist reading James Michener's novel about the Islands. Or they visit Paris, and come home to read Hemingway's A Moveable Feast. Within a week of my return from Scotland, I found myself rummaging through my childhood books for my copy of Robert Louis Stevenson's Kidnapped.

I read Kidnapped as a boy -- my folks had bought it for me along with Treasure Island as a matched set -- and, as I recall, it seemed kind of boring at the time. I read it several years ago as an adult, and found it more captivating. But after visiting Scotland -- having hiked in and about many of the same regions described in the book -- the novel is infinitely more interesting.

Kidnapped is a first-person tale narrated by a Scots teenager from a small town near Edinburgh. The plot is simple. In 1751, David Balfour, having lost both his parents, is cheated out of his inheritance by his uncle, who essentially sells him into slavery to work in the tobacco fields in the American colonies. He is shanghaied aboard a sailing ship, and the first half of the book describes life -- and David's horror and despair -- aboard ship. The ship is wrecked in the Hebrides, off the Isle of Mull. David survives and allies himself with a Highlander named Alan Breck Stewart, a real historical figure.

David and Alan are present when a Campbell clansman -- the Campbells being a clan that willingly acted as agents of the Crown in seizing the property of members of the dissident clans -- was shot and killed upon the highway. The so-called Appin Murder was a national sensation. Warrants were issued for the arrest of both David and his older companion on charges of murder and accessory to murder. The remainder of the story describes their grueling escape from the authorities by way of a circuitous path through the Highlands, back to Edinburgh. It ends with David's being restored to his inheritance.

After an awkward and halting farewell, David walks away into the glittering and busy streets of Edinburgh, well-dressed, with a prosperous life lying ahead. He leaves Alan in hiding, facing a dangerous sail for France, his sole hope for avoiding the noose. David is a well to do Lowlander; Alan, whose unwavering friendship kept David alive, is a dispossessed and despised Highlander.1

I let the crowd carry me to and fro; and yet all the time what I was thinking of was Alan at Rest-and-be-Thankful; and all the time (although you would think I would not choose but be delighted with these braws and novelties)there was a cold gnawing in my inside like a remorse for something wrong.

The novel was serialized in a boys' magazine in 1886, but has always appealed to adults as well as kids. David, a reserved and conscientious "Whig" Lowlander, and Alan, a flamboyantly argumentative Jacobite Highlander, learn to appreciate each other's strengths and overlook each other's weaknesses. The story is satisfyingly biased in favor of the Highlander cause, and the book forces us, and ultimately even David, to root against the English authorities and the quisling Campbell clan.

What's fascinating to me -- aside from the vivid portrayal of one version of real historical events -- is the description of the same countryside that I visited some 260 years later, and of the lives and personalities of the people who inhabited it. Stevenson has his Highland characters speak in dialect when they're speaking English (or Scots, as the dialect is called), as opposed to Gaelic. The author said later that he had anglicized the Scots dialect somewhat to make it more readable, and my edition has a few footnotes defining unfamiliar terms; even so, I suspect that the language would pose a challenge to many kids reading it today.

In fact, the book is impressively sophisticated in language, description, motivation, and characterization, compared with much of what passes as Young Adult fiction -- e.g., vampire books -- today. The long days aboard ship, and the difficulties of hiking secretly through the bracken and heather of the wild Highlands rarely elicit sudden bursts of adrenaline,2 as more modern readers may demand, but rather paint a picture, layer by layer, of the dangers and hardships of life and politics in 18th century Scotland, and the growth of a friendship between two protagonists from opposite backgrounds.

With that caveat, Kidnapped is worth reading for anyone, young or adult, who has an interest in history, and in the traditional life of the Scottish Highlands.

------------------------
1Historically, Alan Breck Stewart was tried in absentia and sentenced to hang. He was never hanged, but no record exists as to his life after leaving Scotland. His father was tried in person as an accessory to the murder. Although no evidence was produced that the father intended the murder or had any part in it, he was convicted by a jury of Campbells and a Campbell judge, and was hanged. Recent historical studies have absolved both Alan and his father of any guilt in the killing. (David, of course, is a wholly fictional character.)

2Although the chapter in which David and Alan singlehandedly mutiny and seize control of the ship headed for the Colonies -- shortly before it runs onto a reef and is wrecked -- is exciting by anyone's standard.

Sunday, August 21, 2011

Folksy writing


My blog's "mission statement" asserts my intent that it be "An exercise in careful writing, traditional grammar and tidy penmanship." And yet my posts are often replete with sentence fragments, slangy terms and unanswerable rhetorical questions.

So what's with that?

In an essay in today's New York Times Magazine, Maud Newton deplores the sloppy conventions, the "folksiness," of today's internet writing in general and of blog composition in particular. She spends much of her essay ascribing today's stylistic morass to the writings of David Foster Wallace, the author whose essay "Consider the Lobster" received extravagant worship from me in an earlier blog posting.

She dislikes Wallace's "second guessing" -- by which she means Wallace's frequent acknowledgement that his own point of view is not without weakness -- and his rapid alternation between formal speech and slacker slang. As example, she presents his felicitous phrase, "hard not to sort of almost actually like," which of course incorporates both "second-guessing" and slacker slang, along with a dollop of equally deplorable self-irony.

In fairness, Newton recognizes that Wallace had a brilliant mind and that his unfortunate style was part of his appeal. What she really hates is how his style has been adopted unreflectively by bloggers of lesser skills and intelligence.

Like me.

Like Newton, I've spent many years engaged in legal writing. And together with Newton, when I write professionally, I agree that the

idea is to provoke and persuade, not to soothe. And the best way to make an argument is to make it straightforwardly, honestly, passionately, without regard to whether people will like you afterward.

But when I do write a brief, my sole purpose is to persuade a judge that no reasonable person could disagree with my argument. I write only to persuade, not to entertain, and not to muse together with my reader on the complexities of life.

This blog is something of an escape from years of legal writing. I write partly to force myself to think clearly about issues I find interesting. I write partly to persuade, just as I do as a lawyer, but also partly to acknowledge that every point of view, including my own, has both merits and weaknesses, and to invite whomever stumbles upon my blog to think for himself.

And, sure -- I write to entertain. To entertain myself as I write -- an admitted self-indulgence -- and to entertain, or at least interest, my readers.

Newton's essay is interesting, and worth considering. There is, in fact, a tendency among modern writers to shun formality, and to write in the same casual manner as we speak. This tendency can be overdone, and the result can be not merely an informal style, but an irritating lack of clarity in expression.

But the writer needs to consider the purpose of his writing. If expressing an argument or fact with clarity is less important than conveying a mood or observing the humor in some quirk of life, the style of writing should -- or, at least, may -- reflect this purpose.

So yeah. What y'all think of that, huh?

Friday, August 19, 2011

Beyond barbarism


One way to identify a primitive society is by its tendency to judge all issues -- political and ethical -- in terms of black and white. Hence, the concept of "taboo" or "kapu," a Polynesian word that also applies to the codes of most early societies. Think, for example, of the lengthy list of absolute prohibitions set forth in the Book of Leviticus.

But religious taboos are merely one aspect -- and not that important an aspect -- of what we might call Manichean thought processes. In 18th century England, theft of a shilling or more was a felony, and whether the judge liked it or not, there was only one penalty for felonies -- hanging. Many a ten-year-old pickpocket found himself strangling at the end of a rope. For whatever cultural or psychological reasons, Republicans even today seem to have a similar -- if less gruesome -- mindset, and a strong aversion to viewing political issues as presenting varying shades of gray. ("No new taxes, whatever the consequences," for example.)

President Obama announced today that he is directing Homeland Security to focus its attention on deporting those illegal immigrants with criminal records who pose a danger to national security or public safety, and to ease up on others -- students and college graduates, especially, who were brought illegally as children to this country. Fox News headlined the President's announcement: "GOP: Obama Giving Free Pass to Illegal Immigrants." Republicans denounced the action as "backdoor amnesty"; the Republican governor of Arizona said Obama was enacting the so-called Dream Act "by executive fiat."1

I still remember the case of Rigoberto Padilla. Padilla was brought here illegally from Mexico by his parents when he was six years old. He had lived in Illinois, never returning to Mexico even for a visit. He graduated from high school with a 3.5 GPA, and, while working full time, was a full time honors student at the University of Illinois at Chicago, where he was also president of a Latino student organization. He planned to attend law school and become an attorney. He was stopped for a minor traffic offense, his immigration status was discovered, and he was given four months to return voluntarily to Mexico -- a country he knew nothing about -- or be deported.2

"He is now going to pay for the sins of his parents, really, and we cannot be making special exceptions for him," said a right-wing activist opposing illegal immigration.

Simple question of black or white.

"No Amnesty" has been the mantra of right-wing opponents to any easing of the immigration laws. Deport them all, they demand, every one of the millions of undocumented immigrants, no matter how long they have been here, no matter how valuable their lives have been to their communities. Their presence somehow is an affront to those of us who, despite having spent our lives sitting slack-jawed before our TV sets, are nevertheless more deserving of this country's amenities, because we happen to have been born here.

Fortunately, the legal system recognizes the concept of  "prosecutorial discretion" -- a concept that reflects the realization that we will never have enough prosecutors or judges to charge and convict every offender against every law on the books. The concept also recognizes that not every technical statutory violation should be prosecuted, even if the resources to do so were available -- in too many cases, the damage to the offender would far outweigh any advantage to the community.

President Obama's guidelines to Homeland Security direct a sensible and compassionate exercise of such prosecutorial discretion.

The ability to weigh offenses on a case by case basis -- both by the prosecutor in deciding whether to charge the offense, and by the courts in determining the proper penalty upon conviction -- reflects our development from a rigid, primitive society to a humane and more reflective community. In other words, our progress beyond barbarism to a tenous status of civilization.

We don't automatically stone wizards, nowadays. (Lev. 20:27) We first ask for more details, and see if there aren't better ways to resolve the problem.

------------------------
Photo: Rigoberto Padilla at press conference

1Interestingly enough, however, over 64 percent of Fox News readers (as of 8-19-11 at 11 a.m. PDT) voted approval for emphasizing deportation of criminals rather than of illegal immigrants in general.

As of 2:00 p.m., over 69 percent were favoring the President's position. And Fox had dropped the entire story out of headline treatment.

2At the last minute, after a public outcry, his deportation was deferred for at least one year.

Monday, August 15, 2011

Land of dreams


Over the past two weeks, while the American economy was falling prey to the dysfunctional American political system, and while the cities of Britain were being burned by hopeless youths, I was hiking obliviously and happily through the Highlands of Scotland.

I've described my anticipated route in past blog postings. The scenery along the trail was beautiful every step of the way, from the pastoral suburbs of Glasgow, past the calm, fjord-like waters of Loch Lomond, into the Highlands, weaving through the crags and bogs of Rannoch Moor, down into the valley of Glen Coe, and back up over a final lobe of Rannoch Moor and down into Fort William.

The predicted rain fell, although not day by day, hour by hour. I had three days during which fairly steady rain fell during at least part of the hiking day: Day 2 approaching Loch Lomond; Day 5 approaching Inveroran on the edge of Rannoch Moor; and the final day, climbing out of Kinlochlevan across moors and mountains to Fort William. It was on that final day that I confronted the steadiest rain, a rain that obscured what was billed as the most beautiful mountain scenery of the hike. I hiked for miles on gully-like trails that flowed with running water as though they were creek beds, being repeatedly forced to find a way across the "burns," or small streams, that flowed across the trail every few hundred feet or so. But then, I'm a Northwest Corner hiker -- not unaccustomed to moisture -- and was able to take that in stride. And I did have appropriate rain gear.

Each day's hike, although usually lengthy, was reasonably gentle, and the trail was extremely well maintained. For a significant portion of the hike, I was hiking on abandoned military roads from the 18th century, roads so well built that they remain in excellent condition and have required little maintenance. My longest day's hike was 18 miles on Day 2, three miles longer than advertised because of a wrong turn I took in extremely heavy rainfall. This misadventure, together with another mistake on Day 4 that led me to make an unnecessary steep climb into the hills, wasting 1½ hours, reflect little credit on the author's navigational skills. Further discussion on this topic, therefore, will not be tolerated.

Midges? A few bites the last three days of the hike, despite my purchase and use of Smidge®, a Scottish concoction designed specifically to battle the midge threat, but the tiny bugs certainly didn't present a serious problem. I've had worse experiences with mosquitoes right here in the good old US of A.

Why hike in Scotland, when we have beautiful trails on which to hike here at home? I sensed that question in the minds of some of the Scots with whom I talked. And if you're looking just for pretty scenery and good trails, the question has a certain validity.

To me, however, there's the additional appeal of historical and literary allusions: Celtic myth, warring clans, Jacobite rebellions against the English, reivers and highwaymen, Rob Roy, Sir Walter Scott. I've also had a strong yearning, ever since childhood, to walk unknown paths shrouded in mists and myth -- that fairy world that makes up so much of Yeats's poetry, perhaps, or the mysterious empty lands of Tolkien's writings. The popularity of the LOTR books and movies surely indicates that I'm not alone in this yearning, in this peculiar need to visit, however briefly, worlds somehow pre-modern in their strangeness and scant population.

Thus, poring over my maps in the months before the hike, I foresaw Loch Lomond as it really is -- a beautiful lake with many historical associations, but also a lake that serves as a recreational area for the urban residents of Edinburgh and Glasgow. But north of the lake, the trail would leave the modern world, in my imagining, and wend its way into the world of romance. I would cross the Bridge of Orchy, an ancient landmark in the wilderness marking the entrance to the moors of the North. A bridge that I somehow associated with Tolkien's Last Bridge, crossing the River Bruinen. I saw myself fighting off Dark Riders in front of me, while defending against trolls attacking my flanks.

The trail enters Rannoch Moor, crossing vast reaches of bog and grasslands -- a playground for Macbeth's witches, for hobgoblins and will-o'-the-wisps -- skirting the base of dark hills with darker names: Beínn Toaig and Meall a'Bhùiridh, Beíenn a'Chrulaiste and Buachaille Etive Mor. It leads down to the isolated Kingshouse Hotel, an ancient establishment that's been greeting travelers, smugglers and cattle drovers for over two centuries, an inn that recalled -- again, in the fevered imaginings of my mind -- Tolkien's "Prancing Pony" inn at Bree. The trail leaves "Bree" behind, and climbs back up to the moor by the sixteen switchbacks of the Devil's Staircase, thence descending into the isolated lochside village of Kinlochleven.

I would be wandering in a land of enchantment.

Now, despite your impression, I'm not an idiot. I know I live in the 21st century. I know that the fairies and goblins have long since been chased from Scotland. But it's possible to think on two levels simultaneously, right? Staring at the map, my rational mind clearly observed that the trail rarely wanders far from the A82 tourist road that runs from Glasgow, north to Fort William, and on to Inverness. But on my trail map, the A82 is merely a faint line, less prominant than the bright red line of the West Highland Way trail. The secret of a successful Scottish hike -- for me -- was to likewise subordinate the sights and sounds of that irritating A82 to the romantic imaginings of my own mind while I was actually on the trail.

This I'm fully capable of doing.

I sometimes think that everything is fiction and that travel is something that happens in your head.
--Paul Theroux

Exactly, Mr. Theroux. Exactly.

So it was a great hike. Wonderful exercise. Dazzling scenery. And eight days walking through mysterious regions where, at any moment, I might have encountered a Celtic sprite, a masked highwayman, a MacDonald or Campbell dressed for battle, a Brigadoon wedding.

I didn't, actually, of course. But what I did see, and even what I only dreamed, was far more enjoyable than watching the nosedive of the American economy and the rioting in English cities. Thanks, Scotland! I'll be back again some day.

-----------------------------------
Photos on Facebook can be seen by clicking here.

Saturday, July 30, 2011

Publication suspended


Finally. Summer has arrived in the Northwest Corner. The sun is bright. The sky is blue. The temperatures are in the high 70's. The breezes are soft and gentle, caressing lightly my arms, legs and face, as I stroll down the sidewalk in shorts and t-shirt.

Seattle at its finest: a summer paradise, short in duration, but generous in its gifts.

Well then! I guess it must be time to go hiking in the Scottish Highlands! Take a look at that ten-day forecast. Yes sir, that's one day of partial sunshine. Does this kid know how to pick 'em? And the midge forecast! -- for indeed there is a Scots webpage ominously reporting the midge forecast -- it's for high levels of biting midges, reaching their highest intensity in Glen Coe, a valley through which I'll be hiking. Silly Yank -- look at him trying to admire the scenery while desperately warding off rain and midge.

So be it. The Northwest Corner now shuts down for vacation break. Come back in mid-August, and see what's on its insane publisher's mind. Learn how his diluvial, rain-sodden hike actually worked out in practice.

(I'm kidding -- I'm gonna have fun, no matter how rebarbative the weather conditions may be!)

Wednesday, July 27, 2011

An icy mountain


To the north, beyond the main range of the Himalayas, emerging from the Tibetan plateau, stands an isolated peak called Kailas. Although only 22,028 feet high, quite low by Himalayan standards, no climber has ever stood on its summit (except, apocryphally, a mystic in ancient times). It may never be climbed.

Kailas is a holy mountain to a number of religions, including Hinduism and Buddhism.

To Hindus, Kailas is identified as the earthly manifestation of the mystical mountain Meru. Living on the summit are Lord Shiva, and his consort Parvati.

To Tibetan Buddhists, atop Kailas is the ice palace of Demchog, a demonic deity wearing a crown of skulls -- perhaps a manifestation of Shiva -- who is usually represented with a blue-skinned body, four faces, and twelve arms, and shown embracing his consort Vajravarahi. Demchog and his consort are locked in an erotic embrace, representing the union of "nothingness" and "compassion."

To the remaining adherents of Bön, the pre-Buddhist belief system of Tibet, Kailas represented the seat of all spiritual power.

Colin Thubron is a travel writer in his early 70's. Over his lifetime, he has written a number of well-received books describing his travels in Asia and the Middle East, beginning with publication in 1967 of his book, Mirror to Damascus. In recent years, he's watched his family die off, one by one. The death of his mother, the last survivor of his family, prompted him to undertake a trek to Kailas, leading to publication this year of his book, To a Mountain in Tibet.

If Eric Newby's book, A Short Walk in the Hindu Kush (discussed a couple of posts ago) was a young man's light-hearted treatment of a taxing and dangerous climbing and trekking expedition, Thubron writes as a much older man, stricken by the deaths of relatives and facing his own mortality. The trek is not easy, but it follows well known trails; Western trekking companies routinely lead treks to the holy mountain. Thubron's trek is far less a perilous adventure into the unknown than was Newby's.

But Thubron's pilgrimage results is a far darker book.

Thubron begins trekking in the far western region of Nepal. He walks over passes through the Himalayas, crosses into Tibet, and arrives ultimately at the foot of Kailas. He then undertakes the kora, the traditional Buddhist and Hindu circumambulation of the mountain, an exercise that will wipe one's soul free of sin. For those with the tenacity to complete 108 circuits during their lifetime, the cycle of reincarnation comes immediately to an end, and the soul enters nirvana.

Few beliefs are older than the notion that heaven and earth were once conjoined, and that gods and men moved up and down a celestial ladder -- or a rope or vine -- and mingled at ease.

Kailas is such a ladder. The mountain was flown to this remote area, according to Buddhist belief, staked in place before devils could pull it underground, and nailed in place by the Buddha himself, preventing the gods from returning it to its origin.

Thubron speaks with many Nepalis and Tibetans on his trek. They are usually friendly. Their lives are very difficult, and often short. Many have suffered at the hands of the Chinese Maoists. Whatever dreams they may one day have dreamt as children rarely survived their teens. Only their religious beliefs give apparent meaning to the limited number of years and opportunities allotted them.

Thubron describes in detail, throughout his trek, the cosmic views held by Buddhists (and to a lesser degree, Hindus). He looks for that same meaning. He longs also to believe.

But he views the beliefs he lovingly describes as an outsider; he sees them as myths that -- however beautiful and suggestive -- were evolved by a primitive civilization. He marvels at the quiet self-confidence of monks with whom he meets; but he asks himself, are they incredibly wise, or simply credulous? Scholarly, or lazy? Are the desperately poor Nepali and Tibetans whom he meets making their way through just one more incarnation on the road to ultimate enlightenment? Or are they leading short, desperate, meaningless lives, ending in wretched deaths.

Thubron completes the 32-mile circuit of Kailas, crossing over its high point, Dröma pass, at 18,200 feet. He feels a sense of accomplishment, but he attains no spiritual revelation, no peace.

The writhing image of Demchog -- the union of "nothingness" and "compassion" -- leaves him neither at peace with his mother's death, nor at ease contemplating his own. A Buddhist monk, in the Tibetan tradition, explains to him that, in reality, there are no gods. Or rather, that the gods are merely guides, helping to lead him to that enlightenment that is man's highest destiny.

I tried to imagine this, but the wrong words swam into my mind: rejected life, self-hypnosis, the obliteration of loved difference. Premature death.

He tells a monk that his understanding of Buddhism is that, at death, everything is shed.

He smiled, as he tended to do at contradiction. "That is so. Only karma lasts. Merit and demerit."
"So nothing of the individual survives. Nothing that contains memory?"
"No." He sensed the strain in me, and with faint regret: "You know our Buddhist saying?"
Yes, I remember.
From all that he loves, man must part.

Thubron has undertaken a fascinating adventure. He has written yet another excellent book. I doubt, however, that he came down from his mountain having achieved the wisdom, the peace, or the hope that he may have sought on its heights. Demchog, in his amalgam of compassion and nothingness, may appear to Western eyes a cruel god.
---------------
Photo: Demchok, enthroned upon Mt. Kailas

Tuesday, July 26, 2011

Hoisted with his own petard


A young coyote, his head stuck in a plastic jar, is wandering around south Seattle, drawing tons of attention from the media.

The coyote apparently found something attractive about the jar. Once he got his head into it, however, he couldn't pull it back out. He's been stuck in his self-inflicted trap for about ten days, floundering around the countryside irrationally. He can't eat or drink.

The jar obviously distorts his view of the world, but so far he's eluded capture. He's terrified of the animal experts who are his only hope of extrication before he dies of thirst and hunger.

Time may be running out for the young pup.

Meanwhile, he's causing a lot of commotion and a lot of anxiety in the community.

Turning now to national news, let's look at the Republicans in Congress ....

Sunday, July 24, 2011

Newby in Nuristan


By 1956, Eric Newby had devoted ten years of his life to working as a dress buyer for a London fashion house. Then one day, discouraged by his future prospects, he sent a telegram to Hugh Carless, a casual friend working as a British diplomat in South America, asking "CAN YOU TRAVEL NURISTAN JUNE?"

Nuristan -- which until 1896, when its people were forcibly converted to Islam, had been called Kafiristan (land of the infidels) -- is one of the most remote and backward provinces in Afghanistan, nestled in the mountains of the Hindu Kush, northeast of Kabul. Afghanistan itself, at the time, was a nation so primitive that it had virtually no paved roads. Carless suggested not only exploring Nuristan, but also bagging a first ascent of near-by Mir Samir (19,878 ft.).

Carless replied "OF COURSE." Newby walked away from his career in the fashion industry. And thus was born his best-selling travel adventure, A Short Walk in the Hindu Kush.

Although Newby's life to that point had been a bit more adventuresome than his account of it suggests -- distinguished military service, and shipping out as an 18-year-old apprentice on a four-masted sailing vessel carrying grain as cargo between Europe and Australia -- neither Carless nor he had any mountaineering experience. To prepare for their adventure, they took a short course in elementary techniques from some experienced climbers, mountaineers who appeared concerned not only for the pair's safety but also for their sanity.

Newby writes in a humorous, self-deprecating and understated style about their efforts to properly outfit themselves and prepare for what he increasingly realized would be a totally foolhardy ordeal. The early chapters read like "Laurel and Hardy Go Mountaineering." Carless appears insouciant and confident; Newby was in a constant state of panic and alarm.

Their travel cross-country from Europe to Kabul was in itself the adventure of a lifetime. Once past Kabul, and on the trail up into the Hindu Kush, Newby's account becomes less manically funny and more humorously observant of the real dangers and problems they encountered. Newby's feet were blistered and in bandages from the outset, and both suffered from chronic dysentary. The local helpers whom they had secured in Kabul were difficult to deal with, often obdurate and unwilling to do what was asked of them, and difficult to communicate with. (Carless did speak Persian, of which the local languages were variants or dialects; Newby spoke only English.) The pack horses were in poor condition, and often terrified by the trail they were forced to follow.

Despite unspeakable hardships, primitive food rations, and unfriendly villagers, the two adventurers dragged themselves up higher and higher into the Hindu Kush. Facing miseries that would cause many experienced climbers to give up, and needing to pull out a sort of "Climbing for Dummies" manual whenever they confronted a technical challenge, they somehow managed to reach a point just 700 vertical feet below the summit of Mir Samir. They could have continued successfully to the summit but for the lateness in the day and their lack of any equipment for an overnight bivouac -- even turning around at that point, they returned to their camp after dark.

Rather than then returning to England, tails between their legs, they proceeded onward with a difficult climb over a mountain ridge and down into the next valley, thus passing into Nuristan. They had a number of adventures among a people so isolated that they thought Newby and Carless must be Russians, with whom they were familiar as rifle salesmen -- and so wild and incomprensible that Newby feared they must be mad.

The book comes with a sketchy map, hand-drawn by the author, on which the reader can follow a dotted line marking Newby's route. The map, indeed the entire trek, brings to mind Frodo's quest in Lord of the Rings. Although no orcs or dwarves come bounding out of any of the many caves Newby and Carless pass, their adventure is odd enough, and divorced enough from how we picture the world of 1956, that we would hardly have been surprised. Newby even happens upon a faded inscription carved into stone in an unknown tongue -- strangely reminiscent of Tolkien's elvish runes.

Until I had read Newby's book, I'd never heard of Nuristan, despite the fact that the remote valley was the core sanctuary of the Afghan opponents to the Russian occupation in the 1980's. We think of Afghanistan as a bleak, ugly country filled with murderous fanatics. But before the Russian invasion in 1979, Afghanistan was a popular stop on the "hippie highway" to India. Newby's book reminds us of how beautiful and undeveloped much of Afghanistan remains, and of how primitive and isolated many of its people were as late as the Eisenhower era. And, for all I know, may still be.

Afghanistan as a tourist (or trekking) destination may seem improbable any time in the near future. It wasn't so long ago, however, that Americans felt the same way about Vietnam.
----------------------------------
Photo: Eric Newby climbing Mir Samir

Saturday, July 23, 2011

Ruddigore


A witch burning at the stake. A cursed baronetcy. An old woman long ago driven mad by scorned affection. A gothic castle. Thunder and lightning. Bewitched paintings whose portraits step out from their frames. A black and red caped villain, sweeping about the stage like the alligators in Fantasia. A jaunty sailor, home from the sea, dancing hornpipes. Two young innocents, absurdly shy and absurdly in love. A background village chorus of singing bumpkins.

Allusions to grand opera: the gypsy scene from Il Trovatore, the mad scene from Lucia di Lammermoor. Gothic romance and Victorian melodrama. A tale of mistaken identity, love thwarted, love regained, happy couplings for all, and all's well that ends well -- all lifted out of Shakespearean comedy.

Yes, it's July again, and time for another Gilbert & Sullivan Society production. This year, it's Ruddigore, a production last presented by the Society in 1995.

In a sense, if you've seen one Gilbert & Sullivan operetta, you've seen them all. But each still has its own special brand of silliness, satire, and satisfying music. Each has its own lyrical tunes, declamatory quasi-recitatives, and an example or two of the trademark -- and highly enjoyable and unforgettable -- G&S patter.

Such patters are often satirical -- satirizing the politics and social mores of the Victorian era, sometimes supplemented by a few updated verses good-naturedly attacking the foibles of our own times and place. Ruddigore has a patter -- presented at a tempo even more breathless than usual -- that's almost post-modern in concept, with its amusing (if unintelligable) self-referential conclusion:

If I had been so lucky as to have a steady brother
Who could talk to me as we are talking now to one another –
Who could give me good advice when he discovered I was erring
(Which is just the very favour which on you I am conferring),
My existance would have made a rather interesting idyll,
And I might have lived and died a very decent indiwiddle.
This particularly rapid, unintelligible patter
Isn’t generally heard, and if it is it doesn’t matter!

The excellent feature of any work by G&S is that it really doesn't matter -- it has no notable redeeming social value -- and yet you walk out of the theater happy, whistling, chuckling, and with no doubt whatsoever that your evening's been well spent.

Ruddigore continues playing at Seattle's Bagley Wright Theater through July 30.

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Chill in Seattle


I'm not wise at all. I told you, I know nothing. I know books, and I know how to string words together -- it doesn't mean I know how to speak about the things that matter most to me.
--André Aciman

Every self-appointed member of the blognoscenti soon finds himself pontificating on topics about which he knows little, but on which he doesn't hesitate to speak at length. Such a self-appointed expert may within a few weeks time spew forth, for example -- in pompous bursts of High Academic English -- unreadable essays on journalism, economics, Shakespearean pot smoking, constitutional theory, the political status of colonial dependencies, and -- as his delusions of grandeur become ever more divorced from reality, and his sentence structures ever more strained -- mathematical discourses on irrational numbers and absurdly simplistic comments on quantum mechanics.

The only cure, aside from psychoanalysis or, perhaps, electroshock therapy, is for the blogomaniac to sit back, breathe deeply, and demand of himself an essay based on his own personal experience -- not on his half-baked book learning. Speak about things that really "matter most to me," in other words.

Take the weather, for example. (In Seattle, that last sentence elicits immediate Henny Youngman-esque rejoinders, ones that I'll now ignore.)

Our relationship with the weather is never abstract, always direct and personal. I understand that most of you fellow Americans are suffering from the much-denied outcome ("liberal pseudo-science!") of global warming. Y'all seem trapped under a one million square mile "heat dome", making your lives a living hell, if news reports are to be believed. But here in the Northwest Corner? Au contraire, mes amis. We're still waiting for summer to arrive.

According to the Seattle Times, we've had 78 minutes of summer so far in 2011 -- right up until this, the 20th day of July. To be precise, we had 12 minutes of summer on July 2, and another 66 minutes (hooray!) of summer on July 6 -- "summer," for our purposes, being defined as any temperature of 80 degrees or higher. This morning, I was so chilly when I got up that I almost turned on the furnace, which would have been in utter violation of my personal furnace ban, running from June 1 to October 1.

Even when it's been "warm" this year -- i.e., over 65 degrees -- it's often been sprinkling.

But here in the Northwest, we resemble our climatic cousins, the English. Like the Brits, we might mutter about the weather, but we'd never move away. When someone tells you that he's leaving Seattle because of the rain, or the lack of sunshine, you can bet he wasn't born here. He's a carpetbagger, an interloper who came here because he was unhappy somewhere else, and who's now moving on because he's unhappy here. But he carries his unhappiness around with him, a little rain cloud above his head. It ain't gonna get no better, no matter where he runs to next.

In my neighborhood -- as in most Seattle neighborhoods -- it's a matter of environmental pride that we not water our lawns in the summer. We watch them turn gradually brown during June, stay brown throughout the summer (needing no mowing!), and come back green and healthy when the rains return in September. But today, I look out my window and what do I see? I see that my lawn, and everyone else's, is as soft and green as though it were April. Rain. Precip. Mother Nature's own sprinkler system. When she slams one door in your face, she hands you a silver lining with the other. So to speak.

It may be cool out this summer, but it isn't cold. I can walk out the door anytime I want, wearing only (above the waist) a t-shirt, and not feel uncomfortable. Just cool. And pleasantly non-sweaty. It may rain, but it rarely pours. I can walk in a summer sprinkle -- still wearing that non-sweaty t-shirt -- and get only pleasantly damp. Wet t-shirts do dry without complication, by the way; that's their big advantage over silk business suits. Which Northwesterners rarely wear. Not even CEO's like Bill Gates.

If this were a "normal" hot summer, spring would have been long over. Only the occasional hardy dandelion would still be displaying a bit of color. But as I walk around the neighborhood today, I'm swimming in vernal abundance, engulfed in sweet smelling floral displays. The flowers began blooming in late January -- a mild winter -- and many are still blooming today.

Sure, we'd like it to be warmer. And sunnier. But we adjust. We still hike -- cool temperatures are great for hiking, and a little rain never hurts. We picnic -- well, yeah, the potato salad does get a little runny, the sandwiches a little soggy, but we just duck for cover. "Someone left the cake out in the rain" -- ah, who cares? We still camp -- we just build the campfire up a little higher, and stake the rain flies a little more securely. The Mariners still play baseball (as if anyone still cared) -- they just close the dome.

Northwest weather teaches us to temper our expectations. To avoid being devastated when the barometer drops. To enjoy the beauty of forests and mountains when they're touched by fog and drizzle, as well as when kissed by the sun. To enjoy what we're doing and the people we're with -- even when the weather isn't "perfect," even when not everything's gone exactly according to plan. To enjoy life all the more, many times, just because it doesn't always go according to plan.

Our weather is flexible, and that may have taught us a bit of flexibility in response. As a result, I submit that we're less apt than many folks living elsewhere to whine at every setback, to complain at every obstruction, to feel devastated at each of life's vicissitudes, to constantly fear we're missing out on something to which we're entitled. We're chill. We go with the flow.

Life in the Northwest Corner's good, very good, even if not perfect.

And that's something I didn't have to learn from books.

Saturday, July 16, 2011

Cheers for the gray lady



I walked out to the sidewalk this morning, picked up my copy of the New York Times, and removed its plastic cover -- soaked with Seattle rain -- with special care. Today, the newspaper seemed more precious and exceptional than usual.

Last night, I'd gone to watch the documentary, Page One: Inside the New York Times, now playing in theaters. The movie, centered on the work of David Carr, media columnist for the NYT, gives an exciting picture of what goes on behind the scenes at the paper. The film focuses especially on the financial crisis resulting from a drop in paid subscriptions and an even more drastic recent drop in advertising revenue, and on the growing rivalry between traditional print newspapers and on-line rivals such as the Huntington Post.

Carr and other Times spokesmen make a compelling case that aggregators of bits of news from all over (which adequately describes most on-line competiters) are no substitute for traditional news organizations that not only collect the news but support correspondents and news bureaus that actively seek it out.

Although the Murdoch scandal had not yet become news when the documentary was filmed, Sam Zell's purchase of the Chicago Tribune and Los Angeles Times were used to illustrate what happens when journalism is viewed primarily as a profit generating business rather than as a profession -- when "give the public what it wants" supersedes editorial judgment as to what is newsworthy. As Carr wrote last Monday in his regular column, discussing the press's role in uncovering the Murdoch scandal:

The Guardian stayed on the phone-hacking story like a dog on a meat bone, acting very much in the British tradition of a crusading press, and goosing the story back to life after years of dormancy. Mr. Murdoch, ever the populist, prefers his crusades to be built on chronic ridicule and bombast. But as The Guardian has shown, the steady accretion of fact — an exercise Mr. Murdoch has historically regarded as bland and elitist — can have a profound effect.

Everyone recognizes the value today's internet resources -- YouTube videos, tweets, citizen reporting -- provide in uncovering facts that otherwise would remain hidden. The Times itself is making increasing use of blogs on its on-line version. But significant stories need more than presentation of a melange of uncoordinated facts. They need the tenacity, organization, and editorial judgment that a good newspaper can bring to bear. (And the film discusses certain self-acknowledged lapses in such editorial judgment that have hurt the Times's credibility.)

The documentary perhaps tries to touch too many bases in an an hour and a half. Its reliance on filmed conversations among editors and writers, and on apparently unrehearsed interviews, may cause the viewer some difficulty in following its argument, and some dismay as topics change just as they are becoming interesting. But the movie -- by these very conversations in the face of deadlines and by the often tense interviews -- strongly conveys the excitement of working for a news organization with a history of excellence, one that considers itself America's "newspaper of record."

The Times editors interviewed in the movie seem optimistic that the NYT will continue as the country's leading newspaper, despite acute pressures upon it, financial and otherwise. An outside expert on media affairs was less sanguine, warning that while print newspapers provide valuable services to the country, and therefore "should" survive, it's a mistake to assume that "should survive" necessarily implies "will survive."

A glance through this morning's New York Times reveals one lengthy story after another, covering complex and crucial national, international, and business news issues. These are factual stories and analytical pieces that I doubt exist elsewhere -- except when blogs, aggregators, and lesser newspapers themselves rely, as they often do, on the original work done by the New York Times.

For years, I've subscribed to the Times's Saturday and Sunday editions. I'm now seriously considering signing up for daily delivery. Maybe that's more daily reading than I can handle -- my original reason for the limited subscription -- but I figure it's the least I can do.

I'd hate to live in a country that relied solely on CNN and Fox News for its understanding of the world.

Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Da capo al fine


I returned, this morning, from my final piano lesson of the "school year," having now completed 1½ years in my latest reincarnation as a piano student. No more lessons until the end of August.

My reaction to my upcoming "vacation" is multi-faceted: First, there's my good, old fashioned "no more classes, no more books" sense of relief. Second, a determination to maintain some sort of regimen of practice throughout the summer, even though I'll be lacking the incentive of preparation for my next weekly lesson. And finally, a contemplation of the past year -- looking back at the progress I've made to date.

Yes, I'm still working primarily on the same Beethoven sonata. To my readers my progress must seem painfully slow. But learning a sonata is a bit like reading a serious novel: each re-reading reveals something new about the author, about his plot and characterization, about the complexities of life -- and about oneself.

No matter how many times I play a passage, my instructor -- while generous with compliments -- has suggestions for how I might play it better. Or observations: Note how the composer returns, over and over, to B-flat, until he finally resolves the extended phrase with a C-minor chord. Or questions: Why do you think Beethoven wrote this phrase as he did? Or analogies: Think of yourself as playing all four parts of a string quartet; give each instrument an adequate opportunity to show off its own performance.

In other words, while helping me to master a sonata, she is also subtly teaching me a tiny bit of musical theory.

"Master a sonata" -- believe me, I have a long way to go. If I were a kid, preparing for a recital, I'd feel that my situation was hopeless. But I'm doing this simply for my own gratification (although, I suppose that someday I'll force family members to sit quietly for 19 or 20 minutes, and listen to the whole shebang.)

Nineteen or 20 minutes. Such a short sonata, compared to the amount of practice and the number of lessons it's taken me to get just this far.

But is it worth it? You bet!